Mother Struggles With Her Three Picky-Eating Children During Mealtime, Ask Reddit For Advice
"They hated it, but I figured they would give in and start eating what I make."
A 28-year-old mom is trying to survive dinner time with three picky eaters, and it is not going smoothly. One minute she is serving chicken à la king with mixed veggies, the next she is watching each kid pick out the parts they hate like it is a sport.
The messy part is that she did not always cook this way. She used to cater to their preferences, but now she is cooking what she wants, hoping they will eventually try it. Meanwhile, her husband is backing the kids, especially after she cooks hot dogs and burgers in ways they do not approve of, and the whole house turns into a debate over who is being “unreasonable.
OP has three kids and is frustrated because cooking for them is a challenge.

The OP prepared chicken à la king with mixed veggies, but each child had some dislikes in the meal.

OP used to cater to her kids' preferences, but now she cooks what she likes and hopes her kids will eventually try her cooking.
Picky eating in children can often be traced back to a variety of psychological factors, including sensory sensitivity and control issues. Research from the University of Pennsylvania indicates that many children who exhibit selective eating behaviors may have heightened sensory sensitivities, where certain textures, smells, or tastes become overwhelming.
This can create a cycle of anxiety around mealtime, leading to further resistance and conflict. Understanding these underlying factors is crucial for parents to navigate this behavior effectively.
When OP served chicken à la king with mixed veggies, the kids treated it like a menu with personal “no thanks” labels.
The challenges faced by the parent in this Reddit post highlight the complexities of picky eating among children. Each child's unique preferences, such as one refusing spaghetti unless it meets a specific criterion, point to a deeper issue that often intertwines with sensory sensitivities and a need for control. This behavior can be indicative of how children respond to changes in routine or new experiences, suggesting that picky eating may extend beyond mere preference.
Addressing the emotional and psychological aspects of a child's food choices is crucial in creating a positive mealtime atmosphere. By understanding these underlying factors, parents can work towards nurturing healthier eating habits, ultimately leading to a more harmonious dining experience for the entire family.
OP cooked hot dogs and burgers differently than how the kids prefer, causing them to be upset, and her husband supports the kids and believes OP's approach is unreasonable.
They should eat what's served, except for medical dietary restrictions.
Reddit
OP's husband should handle grilling and future meal cooking.
Reddit
Additionally, studies suggest that mealtime dynamics can significantly influence a child's relationship with food. When parents exert pressure to eat, it can backfire, leading to increased resistance. Adopting a more relaxed approach, allowing children to explore food at their own pace without pressure, can help reduce anxiety and foster a healthier relationship with food over time.
That is when her husband stepped in, arguing OP’s new “I cook what I like” plan is the real problem.
From a behavioral perspective, parents can benefit from employing positive reinforcement strategies. A study published in the Journal of Abnormal Psychology indicates that rewarding children for trying new foods can gradually reduce picky eating behaviors. This method not only encourages children to explore new tastes but also builds their confidence in trying unfamiliar foods.
However, it's crucial for parents to remain patient and avoid forcing children, as pressure can lead to further resistance and negative associations with food.
If OP's husband supports them, he can cook for them.
Reddit
If they don't like it, they can make a sandwich.
Reddit
OP and her husband are responsible for this behavior, but it's not too late to change it.
Reddit
The mealtime environment plays a significant role in shaping children's eating habits. Research published in the Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior highlights that creating a positive and stress-free dining atmosphere can encourage children to try new foods.
Involving children in meal preparation and making meals visually appealing can also stimulate interest and curiosity about food. These strategies can help children feel more empowered and less anxious about mealtime.
The drama escalated again with hot dogs and burgers, because OP prepared them differently than the kids prefer and everyone got upset.
Family dynamics significantly influence children's eating behaviors.
Parents can create picky eaters by not allowing their children to make their own food.
Reddit
OP could involve children in cooking to make their meals.
Reddit
It's normal for kids not to like some things, but it seems OP is cooking different meals, which they'll eventually get over.
Reddit
Practical solutions to manage picky eating include introducing new foods gradually and pairing them with familiar favorites. Using a 'no thank-you bite' approach, where children are encouraged to taste a new food without the pressure to finish it, can help them develop a more adventurous palate while reducing anxiety.
Moreover, fostering a family culture that values diverse food experiences can create a supportive environment for children to explore different flavors.
Involving children in meal preparation can also be an effective strategy. Studies have found that children who help prepare meals are more likely to try new foods. This hands-on approach empowers children and gives them a sense of control over their eating choices. Furthermore, it can transform mealtime into an enjoyable bonding experience, fostering positive associations with food.
Parents can start by letting children pick a recipe or help with simple tasks, gradually increasing their involvement as they become more comfortable.
Their behavior is unreasonable.
Reddit
Now the thread is split between “eat what’s served” and the idea that the kids’ rules keep changing dinner into a power struggle.
Parents sometimes make picky eaters by giving in to all their food demands. To avoid this, kids can be encouraged to help make their meals sometimes.
It's normal for kids not to like everything, but it seems like these kids are used to getting their way with food, which might not be the best approach.
The kids in this story might be acting a bit unreasonably, but it's not too late for their parents to change this behavior. They can involve the kids in cooking and try to make meals together.
This way, everyone can enjoy meals together without too much fuss.
Long-Term Strategies for Picky Eating
Ultimately, addressing picky eating behaviors requires a multifaceted approach. It’s important for parents to remain consistent and patient, recognizing that change takes time. Keeping a food diary to track food preferences and changes in behavior can provide valuable insights into a child's evolving tastes.
Additionally, consulting a pediatric dietitian can be beneficial for families struggling with extreme picky eating. These professionals can offer tailored strategies that align with the child's unique needs and challenges.
The struggle faced by the Reddit user with her three picky eaters highlights a common challenge many parents experience at mealtime. Each child’s specific preferences can turn a simple task like serving spaghetti into a complex negotiation. The importance of creating a supportive mealtime environment cannot be overstated. When children feel secure, they are often more willing to try new foods. This approach encourages exploration and communication around food, which can ultimately lead to a healthier relationship with what they eat. By fostering a positive atmosphere during meals, parents can help their children gradually expand their food horizons and make mealtime a more enjoyable experience for everyone involved.
Psychological Strategies for Encouraging Healthy Eating
Incorporating psychological strategies can greatly assist in managing picky eaters.
In the quest to tackle the challenges of picky eating, the story highlights the importance of understanding the intricate dynamics of children’s food preferences. The struggles of the parent with three selective eaters illustrate the need for a supportive mealtime environment that fosters exploration rather than restriction. By employing strategies that incorporate positive reinforcement and open dialogue about food, parents can help their children navigate their preferences without feeling pressured.
Moreover, creating an atmosphere of acceptance can significantly impact children's comfort levels with trying new foods. This approach not only helps alleviate mealtime stress but also encourages a more diverse and balanced diet over time, allowing kids to gradually expand their culinary horizons.
The family dinner did not end well, because nobody could agree on who gets to call the shots at the table.
For another family dinner power struggle, read about whether OP should stop sibling’s super spicy dish from being served.