Property Owner Upsets Entitled Neighbors By Putting Up Fence Because It Makes Their Lot "Visually Smaller"

Imagine yourself living in the neighborhood you've always dreamed of. There are plenty of outdoor activities to enjoy, the crime rate is low, and it's simply perfect for your lifestyle.

Alas, life isn't perfect, and there will always be a fly in the ointment. For one Redditor, it's their neighbor.

A man mentioned his mild annoyance in an "Am I The A**hole?" (AITA) subreddit post. The original poster (OP) tells the community that he recently moved into a better neighborhood in a big city suburb with his wife some years ago.

Most of their neighbors are seniors who get along well, except for one couple who lives behind them. The OP explains that he chose the street because of its large lots, which are ideal for their dogs and kids.

Shortly after moving in, the unneighborly couple offered their old patio set, which the OP politely declined. Since then, friction with these neighbors has developed.

They have complained about trivial matters, lied about the property line, and raked leaves onto the OP's property. They even threatened to sue another neighbor over a tree.

During a heated exchange, the OP mentioned putting up a fence. Despite financial setbacks, the OP has begun the process of building the fence, following all regulations and obtaining the necessary approvals.

When a building inspector visited, likely due to a complaint from the neighbors, he confirmed that the OP was doing everything correctly. Another neighbor overheard them complaining about the fence, making the OP feel more justified in building it.

But he still wonders if he's the a-hole for building those fences.

The OP has decided to put up a fence after a heated exchange with a neighbor.

Reddit

The OP and his wife moved into a new neighborhood.

The area was almost perfect, but their neighbors are the problem.

Reddit

The Emotional Landscape of Property Disputes

Conflicts over property boundaries often reveal deeper psychological issues, particularly around ownership and personal space. As noted by Dr. Dan Ariely, a behavioral economist, "Our sense of ownership is deeply rooted in our identity and can lead to strong emotional responses when we feel our territory is threatened." When boundaries are perceived as encroached upon, it can trigger feelings of vulnerability and anger, often leading to defensive behaviors. The upset neighbors may feel a loss of control over their environment, which can manifest as entitlement and resentment, as highlighted by Dr. Lisa Feldman Barrett, an emotion researcher, who states, "Emotions are often responses to perceived threats to our personal space and autonomy."

They bought a property with a large yard so their dogs could run around and their kids could play freely.

Reddit

After the OP refused the neighbor's offer, they became sour toward him.

Reddit

Social psychology reveals that our perceptions of space are not just physical but emotional as well. This is particularly true in neighborhoods where community ties are strong; individuals often feel a sense of 'shared ownership' over communal aesthetics. When the new fence alters this perception, it can lead to feelings of violation and a perceived threat to social cohesion.

According to a study in the Journal of Environmental Psychology, alterations in shared spaces can disrupt established social norms, creating tension among neighbors.

These neighbors were causing inconveniences to the OP and another neighbor.

They were even claiming a portion of the OP's land.

Reddit

So the OP decided to put up a fence. He made sure that he was complying with local standards and regulations.

Reddit

Addressing Neighborly Disputes Effectively

One effective strategy for resolving conflicts like this is through open communication. Experts suggest that initiating a dialogue can help de-escalate tensions and foster understanding. A community mediation approach, where a neutral third party facilitates discussions, can be particularly beneficial in addressing grievances related to boundary disputes.

Additionally, educating neighbors on the psychological impact of perceived territorial encroachments can promote empathy and understanding. Research indicates that when individuals feel heard and validated, they are often more willing to compromise and find mutually agreeable solutions.

A building inspector came for a visit. The OP suspects that the neighbors complained about the posts he started placing.

Reddit

Their other neighbor was happy about what they planned to build.

On the other hand, the problematic neighbors were complaining, especially since they felt their yard had become smaller.

Reddit

Behavioral economics also provides insight into how people value their property. The endowment effect, a cognitive bias where individuals place a higher value on what they own, plays a significant role in these disputes. This phenomenon could explain why the neighbors feel so strongly about the fence, as it represents an alteration of their perceived property value.

Understanding these psychological principles can help property owners navigate such conflicts with greater awareness and sensitivity toward their neighbors' feelings.

If these neighbors are being problematic, the only solution is to put up a fence.

Reddit

The OP also suspects that their neighbors won't consent to his privacy fence, so he needs to look for a workaround.

Reddit

No matter what the OP's neighbors say or complain about, as long as he puts up a fence that meets standards and regulations, they cannot do anything about it. Ultimately, the OP's priority is to ensure his family's comfort and privacy, which the new fence will help achieve despite the neighbors' grievances.

An old adage suggests that it is indeed better to have property fences.

Reddit

He shouldn't feel dumb. We all know who's being unreasonable here.

Reddit

Fences are great for preventing arguments between neighbors. Boundaries need to be respected.

Reddit

Psychological Analysis

This situation exemplifies a common psychological response to perceived threats to personal space. The neighbors' discomfort likely stems from a combination of territorial instincts and an emotional connection to their environment, leading to feelings of entitlement that can escalate conflict.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In summary, property disputes often trigger complex emotional responses rooted in territoriality and identity. Acknowledging the psychological aspects of these conflicts can lead to more constructive outcomes. As noted by Dr. Kristin Neff, a leading researcher in self-compassion, "When we approach conflicts with empathy and understanding, we can transform our relationships and find common ground." Furthermore, Dr. Alexandra Solomon, a relationship expert, emphasizes that "open communication is crucial in resolving interpersonal disputes, allowing individuals to express their feelings and needs effectively."