Woman Sells Sister's Dog She Was Petsitting, Sister Kidnaps Her Pet As Revenge And Bargaining Chip

Generally, if an individual needs help, the first people they can rely on are family and close friends. However, everyone can break their promise for various reasons.

This issue recently happened to a Reddit user, who shared her story online and asked for unbiased opinions regarding her situation. The OP owned a 6-month-old male Greyhound named Goose, a breed she had long desired.

Planning a week-long trip to another state with friends, she needed a caretaker for Goose. Her sister, May, 32, volunteered to watch him, and the OP provided emergency funds for Goose's necessities, trusting May since her 7-year-old niece adored the dog.

The trip was enjoyable until the last day when May informed the OP that Goose had escaped and was missing. Devastated, the OP returned home early but failed to find Goose.

May explained that she had let Goose out to stretch his legs, only to find him gone 20 minutes later. Following a period of depression, the OP's spirits were slightly lifted by her friends' efforts.

The situation took a turn when her best friend discovered a Facebook photo of a family with Goose, identified through one of the niece's friends. The OP immediately reached out to the family, asserting her ownership and begging for Goose's return, even offering payment.

However, the family refused, claiming May said the OP no longer wanted Goose and subsequently blocked her. Confronting May, the OP demanded an explanation after presenting the proof.

May initially denied the accusation but eventually confessed that she sold Goose for financial reasons. In revenge, the OP took May's dog, Dazey, stating that her mental well-being trumped the value of a dog, similar to May's rationale.

The OP threatened legal action unless Goose was returned and was left wondering if her actions were justified.

The OP asks:

Reddit

The OP explained she needed someone to watch her dog while she was on vacation:

Reddit

The OP's sister offered to dogsit her puppy, but she lost it while the OP was away:

Reddit

The Psychological Implications of Betrayal

Dr. Mark Fields, a psychologist specializing in family dynamics, explains that betrayal, especially between family members, can lead to significant emotional distress. His research indicates that such actions often trigger feelings of anger, sadness, and confusion, which can deeply affect family relationships. The act of selling a pet, especially without consent, can be perceived as a profound violation of trust.

Research in the Journal of Family Psychology shows that betrayal can lead to long-term estrangement if not addressed properly, making it crucial to navigate these feelings with care.

Sister told her he ran off, but shortly after the OP saw pictures of her puppy on social media:

Reddit

The OP contacted the family to return her dog, but it turned out her sister sold him:

Reddit

After confronting the sister, the OP took her sister's dog hostage:

Reddit

From a behavioral perspective, such drastic actions can be indicative of underlying psychological issues, such as impulse control problems or unresolved conflicts. Individuals who act out of anger or desperation may not fully comprehend the consequences of their actions, suggesting a need for emotional regulation strategies to manage intense feelings.

Now, the OP wonders if her reaction was wrong:

Reddit

If the dog is chipped, the OP can report it stolen to take it back

Reddit

Another Redditor agreed

Reddit

Navigating Conflict Resolution

When dealing with family disputes, effective conflict resolution techniques can facilitate healthier outcomes. Experts recommend using techniques like active listening and 'I' statements to express feelings without escalating tensions. For instance, saying 'I feel hurt and betrayed by your actions' can open the door for more constructive discussions.

Additionally, seeking the help of a family therapist can provide a neutral space for discussing grievances and rebuilding trust.

The OP responded:

Reddit

The OP should report it

Reddit

The OP didn't have the right to steal her sister's dog

Reddit

Understanding the psychological dynamics at play can also involve examining attachment styles. Individuals with insecure attachment may react more strongly to feelings of betrayal, as their ability to trust others may already be compromised. Addressing these attachment issues through therapy can help individuals develop healthier relationships with family and pets alike.

The OP should have taken legal action, not revenge

Reddit

It's the proper way to manage the situation

Reddit

Redditors told the OP that although her sister sold her dog, she didn't have the right to steal hers. The only suitable way to handle the situation was to call the police and report the case.

Therefore, they advised the OP to return her sister's dog and report what happened to hers.

Building a Supportive Network

Creating a support system outside of the immediate family can be beneficial in navigating feelings of betrayal. Friends, support groups, or community organizations that focus on animal welfare can provide emotional support and constructive advice during this challenging time. Engaging with others who have faced similar situations can also help validate feelings and provide guidance on moving forward.

Psychological Analysis

This situation highlights the emotional turmoil that can arise from family betrayals, particularly when pets are involved. It's essential to approach these conflicts with empathy and to seek support to process feelings of hurt and betrayal effectively.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In summary, betrayal within family dynamics can have profound psychological effects that require careful navigation. Research shows that addressing these feelings through open communication and therapeutic support can facilitate healing and restoration of trust. By fostering a supportive environment, individuals can work towards rebuilding relationships affected by betrayal.