Setting Boundaries - Dealing with Boyfriend's Best Friend Always Third Wheeling

Are you the jerk if you ask your boyfriend to stop bringing his best friend everywhere? This dilemma faces a 16-year-old who feels like a third wheel in her own relationship with her 17-year-old boyfriend of 7 months.

Despite wanting alone time with him, his 18-year-old best friend seems to tag along everywhere, even inserting himself into their intimate moments. The situation becomes awkward, with the best friend making moves that suggest a rivalry for the boyfriend's attention.

Commenters weigh in, some suggesting that the boyfriend might have more than a platonic relationship with his best friend, while others advise clear communication and setting boundaries. The consensus is that the boyfriend should prioritize his girlfriend's feelings and address the issue.

The Reddit thread showcases different perspectives on handling relationship dynamics and emphasizes the importance of open communication in resolving conflicts.

Original Post

I (16F) and my BF (17M) have been together for around 7 months. We are really close, and I’m not able to see him a lot outside of school, mostly because he lives far away and doesn’t have the money for dates and such.

At school (and outside of school), he’s always with his BFF (18M). I understand this because I also only have one close friend, but the thing is, he brings his BFF around everywhere.

Whenever he and I want alone time for just a couple of hours, his BFF has to come. When I plan something fun for us, his BFF has to come. When I want to play video games with him, his BFF doesn’t play video games, but he will stay and try to insert himself into our conversations.

When it was our 6-month anniversary, I got him a gift (we were both really busy with school and wrestling, so we decided to go out over the weekend) and invited him to sit outside with me so we could exchange gifts and hang out for maybe 20-30 minutes before practice. His BFF came and kept touching him in front of me in a way that suggested, “Oh, your boyfriend likes me more than you, haha.”

I told him about this before, and he said that his BFF just follows him around even when he wants to be alone. He said he would try to talk to him, but his BFF is very stubborn.

This continues to happen, and on Monday, I went to see my BF at the park, and we were supposed to have a little picnic. His BFF was there.

Announced. And I ended up alone.

I’m leaving for a vacation on Monday, and I really just want quality time with my BF before I leave, but I think his BFF is just going to follow us around. (Also, I think this is necessary information, but he and his BFF live in the same apartment area.

I don’t want to say complex because they live directly across from each other. So whenever my BF wants to walk over to the park or somewhere, his BFF usually just follows.) WIBTA if I tried to set more boundaries about our hangouts/dates?

The Role of Boundaries in Relationships

Setting boundaries is an essential aspect of any healthy relationship, and it often becomes necessary when a partner's friend is perceived as intrusive. According to research published in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, boundaries help define personal space and emotional safety.

When these boundaries are respected, relationships tend to flourish; when they are violated, feelings of frustration and neglect can arise.

Comment from u/srgonzo75

Comment from u/Beachside93

Psychologist Dr. James K. Smith emphasizes that feeling overshadowed by a partner's friend can lead to feelings of inadequacy or jealousy. This response is often rooted in deep-seated fears of abandonment or unworthiness.

Understanding the psychological triggers behind these feelings can help individuals articulate their needs more effectively.

Comment from u/Muffin-Faerie

Comment from u/wesmorgan1

Communicating Boundaries with Compassion

Effective communication of boundaries is crucial in navigating relationships with external parties. Using 'I' statements to express feelings about the friend's presence can minimize defensiveness in your partner.

For example, saying 'I feel overshadowed when your friend is always around' shows vulnerability and can encourage a supportive dialogue.

Comment from u/rabidgonk

Comment from u/WhereWeretheAdults

Additionally, framing the conversation in terms of how the situation affects the relationship can lead to greater understanding. Studies show that discussing feelings rather than accusations can lead to more constructive outcomes.

This approach fosters a sense of teamwork in addressing the issue rather than creating an adversarial atmosphere.

Comment from u/Mia-blissGG

Comment from u/Ihatemongo

The Impact of Third Parties in Relationships

Having a third party involved in a romantic relationship can create feelings of competition and insecurity. Research indicates that when a partner's friend takes up significant time, it can lead to a sense of neglect and questioning of the relationship's stability.

Such dynamics can foster unhealthy competition for attention and validation, which can be damaging over time.

Comment from u/Due-One-4470

Comment from u/Rocketstiltskin

To address these issues constructively, couples can benefit from establishing joint activities that include the friend but also reinforce the couple's bond. Engaging in shared experiences can help mitigate feelings of exclusion and enhance relationship quality.

Moreover, discussing how to prioritize time together can also be an effective solution.

Comment from u/It_is_average_size_

Comment from u/Emergency-Bag-2249

Seeking Support for Relationship Challenges

If boundary-setting proves difficult, couples therapy can provide a supportive environment to address these concerns. Therapists can guide couples in developing communication skills tailored to their unique dynamics.

Research indicates that effective therapy can lead to improved relationship satisfaction and understanding, especially when external pressures complicate dynamics.

Comment from u/barryburgh

Comment from u/Current_Echo3140

We're curious to hear your perspective. Share your thoughts in the comments.

Comment from u/cmrtl13

Comment from u/carton_of_cats

Comment from u/Auntie_Social_1369

Comment from u/Dizzy-Case-3453

Psychological Analysis

This scenario illustrates the complexities of navigating relationships with external influences. The presence of a third party can often trigger insecurities and fears, highlighting the importance of clear communication and boundary-setting in maintaining a healthy romantic partnership.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, boundaries are essential for healthy relationships, and recognizing when they are being crossed is the first step toward restoring balance. Research suggests that open communication is key to addressing these issues effectively. By fostering understanding and empathy, couples can navigate the complexities of external relationships together.