Should I Bring My Baby To Small Group? AITA For Not Getting Childcare?

A 28-year-old woman is running a church small group for young adults, and she’s getting hit with an awkward request that basically turns into a baby-versus-belonging showdown. The group, called Figuring It Out, meets every other week in her home, and she and her husband take turns hosting with another couple.

Here’s the complication: her daughter is 7 months old, and she has been there the whole time. She’s not crying or fussy, just making normal baby sounds while people talk. Still, her best friend from college, who’s one of the couples hosting this week, keeps pushing for childcare, even offering to bring in a teen from the church to watch the baby in a separate room.

What starts as “just minimize distractions” ends with OP questioning whether her own friend is really being supportive.

Original Post

Update: This is a church group called Figuring It Out that I founded and took turns leading out of my home every other week. The group consists of people ages 18-25 since our small church doesn't have a college, married, singles, moms, and young family group to meet everyone's specific life situation.

My friend wanted me to get childcare every week. We don't know anyone with experience babysitting and honestly can't really afford it right now.

Thanks for all your responses! We have stepped down from the leadership position and found a church group for families that integrates young children.

1.5 years ago, my husband and I formed a small group for young adults at our church, where we took turns hosting with another couple. The small group consists of two married couples, two engaged couples, a mother and her toddler, and a few singles.

Seven months ago, I had my beautiful daughter, who has been present while hosting and attending small group. The couple we co-host with started asking if we would want childcare a few weeks ago to minimize distractions.

We expressed multiple times that we are not comfortable leaving her with a sitter yet, especially not for small group nights hosted in our own home. Some nights she's more vocal than others, but she's never crying or fussy—just making baby sounds and playing.

This week, it's their turn to host, and she put in the group text to let her know if we will be getting our own childcare or if she will find a teen from the church to provide it at her house in a separate room. I explained previously that everyone would definitely still hear her in the room next door, and that I doubt a teen girl my baby has never met would know how to keep her happy, so that would likely be counterproductive.

The couple hosting is my best friend from college, and I'm shocked and confused about why she's taking such an issue with my baby being at small group. The other mom-daughter duo moved and only comes occasionally, so this feels pretty targeted toward me.

I plan to step down and find a young families small group to attend with my daughter, but AITA here?

The Intersection of Parenting and Social Norms

This situation illustrates the tension between parenting choices and social expectations. Research in social psychology suggests that cultural norms often dictate how parents manage their children's presence in adult settings. This can lead to feelings of inadequacy or criticism when individuals feel pressured to conform to these norms, especially regarding infants in social gatherings.

Developmental psychology emphasizes that children's needs should be balanced with the social and emotional needs of their parents. This balance can create a more harmonious environment for everyone involved, allowing families to navigate social situations more comfortably.

Comment from u/quondam_et_futuras

Comment from u/OlympiaShannon

The “Figuring It Out” group has always included the baby, so OP thought this week would be the same, until her co-host started pushing childcare again.

Understanding the dynamics of adult-only gatherings can also highlight the importance of social support for parents.

Comment from u/notlucyintheskye

Comment from u/Pristine_Main_1224

Empathy plays a crucial role in navigating social interactions, especially among parents.

Comment from u/Disastrous-Nail-640

Comment from u/TeenySod

When OP reminded everyone the baby’s sounds would still be heard next door, her best friend from college acted like that was the problem.

To address the concerns about bringing a baby to gatherings, practical strategies could include open discussions prior to events. Parents can communicate their needs and expectations, allowing for a shared understanding of how best to navigate social situations. This aligns with the principles of assertive communication, where expressing one's needs while respecting others can lead to more satisfying interactions.

Additionally, considering alternative arrangements, such as designated family-friendly gatherings, may provide a solution that accommodates all parties' comfort levels.

Money stress feels similar to OP fighting siblings over selling their childhood home for financial stability.

Comment from u/ZipperJJ

Comment from u/Organic-Mix-9422

Balancing Parenting and Social Life

Balancing parenting and social life is a common challenge for many families.

Comment from u/Livinthebilif3

Comment from u/k23_k23

Now that it’s their turn to host, the co-host texts the group about whether OP will bring childcare or if they’ll “find a teen” to watch the baby at their house.

How would you handle this situation? Let us know in the comments.

Comment from u/Excitedly_bored

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/Fresh_Caramel8148

Comment from u/WomanInQuestion

Comment from u/Affectionate-Echo22

Comment from u/Indigo_3786

Comment from u/BluePopple

Comment from u/EBSD

OP is left stunned because the other mom-daughter duo barely shows up anymore, and this feels personal when her baby is the one being treated like the disruption.

The debate surrounding the presence of the baby in the young adults' church group highlights the intricate dynamics of parenting within social circles. The original poster's dilemma reflects a broader issue where personal choices collide with group expectations. This situation underscores the importance of empathy and dialogue among friends. By fostering an environment that respects various parenting approaches, the group can not only support one another but also enrich their collective experience. Striking a balance between social engagement and parenting responsibilities is essential for nurturing meaningful connections.

OP might be the one who ends up stepping down, even though her baby was never the reason the group fell apart.

For more pregnancy-fueled conflict, read why OP postponed the wedding after the unexpected pregnancy.