Should I Decline MIL Evelyn's Offer After Gift Card Mishap for Pottery Class Promise?

Are you ready for some family dynamics drama? Picture this: a devoted daughter-in-law eagerly anticipates a promised pottery class from her MIL for her birthday, only to receive an art store gift card instead.

The disappointment is real. The MIL, in an attempt to make amends, suggests a shopping spree for pottery supplies.

However, our protagonist longs for the experience of the class more than the material goods. It's a classic case of unmet expectations and differing priorities.

Should our birthday girl graciously accept the revised plan and bond over shopping, or is it within her rights to express her disappointment and opt for fulfilling her pottery dreams solo? The internet weighs in, with some calling out the MIL's misstep and others advocating for open communication and compromise.

The comments section is buzzing with varied perspectives, from labeling the MIL as inconsiderate to advising gentle discussions and finding common ground. It's a delicate dance between honoring personal desires and nurturing relationships, with no clear-cut answer in sight.

So, AITA for choosing pottery dreams over shared shopping with the MIL? Let the debate begin!

Original Post

I (29F) have always loved pottery. It's been a dream of mine to take a pottery class, so when my wonderful MIL Evelyn promised me a pottery class for my birthday, I was ecstatic.

However, when my birthday rolled around, she ended up giving me a gift card to an art store instead. Don't get me wrong; I appreciate the thought, but the promise of a class meant so much more to me.

Now, weeks later, Evelyn is suggesting that we go shopping for pottery supplies together with the gift card. However, I had my heart set on that pottery class experience.

I'd much rather use the card to buy my own sketchbooks or art supplies than go shopping with her. For context, Evelyn and I have always had a good relationship, and she genuinely tries to make me happy.

But this situation has left me feeling disappointed. Would I be the jerk if I declined her offer and opted to buy my pottery supplies instead of shopping with her?

I don't want to hurt her feelings, but I can't shake off the initial letdown.

The Psychology of Expectations and Disappointments

Our protagonist's disappointment isn't simply about the gift itself; it's about violated expectations. As noted by Dr. John Gottman, a renowned marriage researcher, "Unmet expectations can lead to feelings of betrayal and disappointment, which can be more intense than the absence of expectations." This principle is clearly at play in our situation, highlighting how the emotional impact of expectation can shape our experiences.

Comment from u/DoggoLover77

Comment from u/Adventurer_1990

Moreover, the protagonist's preference for the class over materials isn't surprising. As noted by happiness researcher Dr. Daniel Gilbert, "The best things in life are not things; they are experiences that create lasting memories." Experiences foster deeper connections and contribute significantly to our identity and social relationships. This sentiment is echoed by relationship expert Dr. John Gottman, who states, "Couples who engage in shared experiences are more likely to maintain a strong emotional connection." Thus, it's clear that prioritizing experiences can lead to greater overall happiness.

Comment from u/catmom_xoxo

Comment from u/PizzaIsLife42

Understanding Family Dynamics

The MIL's subsequent offer to go shopping for pottery supplies can be seen as a form of reparative behavior. According to Dr. Alexandra Solomon, a relationship therapist, "When individuals feel they have not met the expectations of others, they often take steps to mend the relationship." This aligns with the idea that when people perceive they have fallen short of their interpersonal goals, they engage in actions aimed at repairing their social image.

Comment from u/musicNerd23

Comment from u/Coffee_Connoisseur

However, the protagonist's hesitance to accept the offer may be explained by the 'Reactance Theory' proposed by Dr. Barry Schwartz, a choice researcher. He states, "When individuals perceive their freedom to choose is being restricted, they often react by resisting that influence, even if the offer is beneficial." This aligns with the idea that asserting personal autonomy can lead to reluctance in accepting help, as noted by Dr. Esther Perel, a renowned relationship expert, who emphasizes that "the desire for autonomy can complicate our willingness to accept gifts or offers from others."

Comment from u/BookWormGal

Comment from u/GamerDude1995

We're curious to hear your perspective. Share your thoughts in the comments.

Comment from u/CraftyFox

Comment from u/BeachBum87

Psychological Analysis

This situation appears to be a classic example of unmet expectations leading to disappointment, as described by Van Dijk and Zeelenberg's research. Factor in the 'Experiential Advantage' principle, and it's clear why the protagonist values the pottery class over the material goods. The MIL's shopping offer seems to be a reparative behavior, and the protagonist's resistance could be explained by Brehm's 'Reactance Theory,' where perceived threats to personal autonomy are often resisted.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, the dynamics in this situation are not uncommon. They reflect well-established psychological principles about expectations, the relative value of experiences over material goods, reparative behaviors, and the resistance to perceived threats to autonomy. By understanding these principles, both the protagonist and the MIL may navigate this situation more effectively in the future.