Should I Have Told My Girlfriend About My Daughter's Phobia?

It’s one thing to date someone and keep the peace, it’s another when your kid’s fear turns a birthday pool party into a full-on family disaster. In this Reddit post, a 50-year-old dad, OP, is trying to do the right thing by protecting his daughter’s privacy, even though everyone else seems to assume she’s just acting moody.

OP’s daughter, 16, developed an extreme phobia of water after a near-drowning when she was 4. She won’t even take baths, only showers. So when Sarah, his girlfriend, invites them to her parents’ pool party, the daughter insists on going, gets tense around the water, and snaps at her younger brother, yelling, “I don’t want my brother to drown.”

That one moment is where Sarah decides OP is hiding something, and the whole relationship storyline blows up fast.

Original Post

I (m50) have been dating my girlfriend, whom we'll call Sarah (f45), for a little over a year. I have two kids: a daughter (16) and a son (13).

When my daughter was 4, she almost drowned during swim lessons and has since developed an extreme phobia of water. It's bad to the point where she won't even take baths, only showers.

My son knows how to swim and is a good swimmer. However, my daughter, being the older sister, is protective of her younger brother, even when it comes to swimming and the water.

Sarah's parents have a pool at their house. Today, we were going over for a pool party to celebrate one of Sarah's nephews' birthdays, who has become good friends with my son.

I told my daughter multiple times that she didn't have to go, that I would check in with her, and she could just relax at home or hang out with friends. She insisted on going to the pool party.

My daughter always tends to get on edge and even a little irritable when near water. Today was no different; to anyone who didn't know, she would have seemed like a moody teenager bossing her brother around.

Sarah started getting on my daughter for bossing her brother around. Eventually, my daughter got irritated and loudly yelled at her, 'I don't want my brother to drown.'

She then ran out crying. Sarah looked at me, confused, and I quietly explained my daughter's experience at 4 and that she has a phobia of water.

Sarah got really mad at me for not telling her. I explained that it is not something my daughter is proud of—that she can't swim and has a fear of water—and that I'm not going to tell everyone because it's not my place. My daughter is old enough to explain that to people if she wants to.

Sarah ended up calling me a horrible dad and an a**hole for not explaining that and letting people think my daughter is just a moody teen. I ended up just leaving and taking my kids home; we haven't talked since, and Sarah told me to leave her alone for a few days.

Phobias in children often stem from traumatic experiences, as highlighted by the father's account of his daughter's near-drowning incident. This context sheds light on the importance of transparency in relationships, especially when it comes to significant emotional issues. The father's decision not to disclose his daughter's water phobia before the pool party not only raises questions about his communication with his girlfriend but also about the potential impact on his daughter's emotional development. Understanding and discussing fears can provide children with a sense of validation, which is crucial for their coping strategies. In this situation, the need for open dialogue becomes evident, as it can foster a supportive environment for both the child and her father’s partner.

Comment from u/lalalajdbfhe

Comment from u/Vibin0212

Sarah’s parents’ pool party was supposed to be fun, but OP’s daughter’s water panic made her look like she was just “bossing” her brother for attention.

Failing to communicate about a child's phobia can lead to misunderstandings, potentially resulting in increased anxiety and embarrassment for the child.

Comment from u/lame_narcissist

Comment from u/notthedefaultname

In the context of relationships, the importance of transparency regarding personal challenges, such as a child's phobia, cannot be overstated. The father's decision not to disclose his daughter's severe water phobia before the pool party raises questions about trust and understanding in their relationship. By withholding this information, he may have unintentionally created a barrier that could prevent his girlfriend from fully supporting him and his daughter during challenging situations. Open communication about such vulnerabilities is crucial for fostering emotional intimacy and connection, allowing partners to better navigate difficulties together. Ultimately, this sharing can fortify the bond between them, transforming potential misunderstandings into opportunities for growth and support.

Comment from u/Aussiealterego

Comment from u/IcePrincess_Not_Sk8r

When Sarah started chewing her out for controlling her brother, OP’s daughter finally exploded with the real reason, and it was instantly too much for everyone else to handle.

Implementing strategies to communicate openly about a child's fears can empower parents to create a supportive environment.

Comment from u/razzledazzle626

Comment from u/redd-junkie

Building Coping Mechanisms

Helping children develop coping mechanisms for their phobias is crucial for their emotional health.

Studies indicate that cognitive-behavioral techniques, such as gradual exposure and positive reinforcement, can significantly reduce the intensity of phobias.

Bill tension can get messy too, like when coworkers argued over splitting an expensive dish after one person ordered it: split the restaurant bill evenly with coworkers after ordering an expensive dish.

Comment from u/Prudent_Designer7707

Comment from u/Carma56

After OP explained the near-drowning and the phobia, Sarah flipped from confused to furious, calling him a horrible dad for not warning her earlier.

Encouraging parents to remain patient and supportive while addressing their child's fears can facilitate emotional growth.

Using relaxation techniques, such as deep breathing and visualization, can also help children manage their anxiety when facing feared situations.

It's important for parents to model healthy coping strategies, demonstrating that it's okay to confront fears together.

Comment from u/ariesrising03

Comment from u/Regular-Butterfly120

We'd love to hear your take on this situation. Share your thoughts below.

Comment from u/spaceace23

Comment from u/WholeAd2742

Comment from u/C04RIO

Comment from u/JamSkully

Comment from u/PaperRings85

Comment from u/Karma-Chameleon_

Comment from u/barnowl1980

Comment from u/sprinklecunt

Now OP has taken the kids home, they have not talked since, and Sarah is telling him to leave her alone for a few days over a secret he didn’t feel entitled to share.

In this scenario, it becomes evident that open communication regarding a child's phobias is crucial for fostering their emotional health. The father’s decision to withhold information about his daughter’s extreme fear of water before the pool party not only placed her in a distressing situation but also potentially strained the relationship with his girlfriend. This incident highlights the importance of transparency in relationships, especially when children’s well-being is at stake. Addressing and understanding these fears can lead to healthier emotional outcomes for both the child and the family unit, suggesting that such discussions should not be avoided but rather embraced for the sake of nurturing a supportive environment.

The birthday party ended, but OP is still stuck wondering if he really should have broken his daughter’s trust to keep Sarah from getting mad.

After Sarah’s “water only” rules, see how one roommate’s smaller room sparked an AITA rent fight, here: roommate pays more rent for her smaller room.