Should Kids Be Banned From Graduation Party - AITA For Suggesting It

Are you the a**hole for suggesting your sister shouldn't bring your nephews to her graduation party? Your sister is graduating, and your mom plans a rooftop party at your workplace, where you offered to help coordinate.

But here's the catch: your nephews, aged 4-10, are a handful in public settings. Last week at Top Golf, they caused chaos, leaving you stressed and anxious.

The party will be mostly adults, and a rooftop isn't safe for unsupervised kids. You proposed an adults-only event, but your mom insists the kids should be there to celebrate.

You fear being responsible for managing them and risking a disaster at work. Are you in the wrong here?

People suggest setting clear boundaries, expressing concerns, or finding a compromise. Some feel your job could be at stake, while others emphasize the importance of professionalism.

It's a tough spot balancing family expectations and professional responsibilities. What's your take on this delicate situation?

Original Post

My sister is graduating from a local university, and my mom wants to throw her a rooftop party at the boutique hotel where I work. I get discounts there and offered to help coordinate since it’s a gorgeous space.

But here’s the issue: I’ll be responsible for the event, and I’m really worried about the kids — specifically my younger nephews (ages 4–10). I love them, and I’m the “fun uncle” who takes them out a lot.

However, they don’t have much self-control in public settings. Last week at Top Golf, they kept running into the play area, wouldn’t sit still, and I ended up having a full-blown anxiety attack trying to keep them safe while the adults barely helped.

This party will mostly be adults, and a rooftop isn’t exactly a safe space for wild, unsupervised kids. So I suggested we make it adults-only.

My mom was offended and said the kids should be there to celebrate. I understand that, but I’m the one on the hook if anything goes wrong — and history tells me I’ll end up babysitting again.

I don’t want to be the bad guy, but I also don’t want a disaster at my job. AITA?

*****UPDATE*****
Here are some things that are up for consideration. The rooftop is gated, specifically 3 feet 5 inches.

I voiced my concern to my mom and my other sibling. My mom sounded like she understood the issue and was willing to come to a compromise.

- Maybe someone can babysit the children in a separate room. - My sister says that she would designate a specialized seating area for them as the venue has patio furniture we’ll use.

- Which is fine, but who’s to say they’ll hold the children accountable and actively keep them seated? As of now, I’m leaning towards the latter, but I think I might wind up being the one responsible for sitting in the hotel room with them. ______Update____
Sorry, I should’ve clarified.

While I did offer to coordinate the gathering, I’m NOT the one who chose the space; my mother and siblings did.

I did express my concerns before they submitted the application to reserve the spot. However, I’m hearing you all loud and clear.

I’m going to make a reservation for a suite for them to go to and maybe play video games to keep them occupied. They can come out for pictures and such and give hugs, hellos, and goodbyes, because I’d much rather not stress anyone out, including myself.

Navigating Social Expectations and Safety

This scenario raises important questions about safety and social expectations in family gatherings. Research in behavioral psychology indicates that concerns about safety, especially in environments with children, are deeply rooted in parental instincts. When planning events, parents often weigh their desire to celebrate with the need to ensure a safe environment for all attendees, particularly children.

According to studies published in the Journal of Family Psychology, parents often feel a heightened sense of responsibility during social events, which can influence their decisions about guest lists and activities.

Comment from u/CrewelSummer

Comment from u/Galadriel_60

Moreover, societal perceptions of children in adult spaces can create tension. Social norms dictate that certain environments should be child-free, often to maintain a specific atmosphere or reduce potential disruptions. Understanding these dynamics can help families navigate the complexities of event planning while respecting diverse opinions about children’s presence.

It’s crucial to recognize that these concerns often stem from a desire to create a memorable and safe experience for everyone involved.

Comment from u/Emergency_Cherry_914

Comment from u/Traditional_Taro8156

The Importance of Clear Communication

Clear communication among family members is essential in navigating event planning. Research in communication theory emphasizes that misunderstandings can arise when expectations are not clearly articulated. In this case, the suggestion to exclude children may not only reflect safety concerns but also a desire to maintain a particular ambiance.

Opening a dialogue about these expectations can foster understanding and help prevent feelings of hurt or resentment. This aligns with principles of effective communication, which stress the importance of expressing needs and listening to others’ perspectives.

Comment from u/Nester1953

Comment from u/MISKINAK2

To address the concerns surrounding the graduation party, practical strategies could include discussing the rationale behind the suggestion to limit child attendance. Sharing insights about safety concerns and the desired atmosphere can create a collaborative decision-making process. This approach not only respects the sister’s perspective but also reinforces the importance of safety in social gatherings.

Additionally, offering alternative arrangements for childcare during the event may alleviate some tension, allowing parents to participate while ensuring children are cared for in a safe environment.

Comment from u/meekonesfade

Comment from u/liteliya2

Creating Inclusive Celebrations

Creating celebrations that respect everyone's needs is crucial for fostering harmonious family relationships. Research in social psychology suggests that inclusive events can enhance family bonds by allowing all members to feel valued and heard. Finding ways to incorporate both adult and child-friendly elements into gatherings can create a more enjoyable experience for everyone.

For example, designating specific areas for children with activities can allow them to play while adults engage in conversation. This balance can help accommodate diverse needs and create a more inviting atmosphere.

Comment from u/ToriBethATX

Comment from u/Bleu5EJ

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

Comment from u/AdventureThink

Comment from u/littlebitfunny21

Comment from u/k23_k23

Comment from u/Disastrous-Nail-640

Comment from u/R4eth

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/frlejo

Psychological Analysis

This scenario encapsulates the challenges families face when balancing safety and social expectations. It's essential to recognize that these decisions often stem from a place of care and concern. Open communication about these issues can help families reach a consensus that respects everyone's views.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Balancing safety concerns with social expectations in family gatherings requires clear communication and empathy. By openly discussing the importance of maintaining a safe environment and embracing inclusive celebrations, families can navigate these complexities more effectively. Ultimately, fostering understanding can lead to deeper connections and more enjoyable shared experiences.