Should I Let My Homeless Brother Move Back In After Trashing My House? AITA?

AITA for refusing to let my homeless brother move back in after he trashed my house last time? Family pressures me but I stand my ground.

Damjan

Published in Interesting
24 Dec 2025

Should I Let My Homeless Brother Move Back In After Trashing My House? AITA?

In a world where family ties often dictate our choices, the story of a young woman navigating the complexities of familial responsibility has sparked a heated debate on Reddit. A 24-year-old homeowner is facing backlash from relatives for refusing to let her 31-year-old brother move back in after he previously left her house in disarray and broke several important agreements.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

Despite his claims of having secured a new job and a promise to follow the rules this time around, the sister is understandably hesitant. Her brother’s past behavior included not only a lack of financial contribution but also chaotic living conditions that turned her home into a source of stress rather than solace.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

Now, as he finds himself homeless once again, family members are urging her to give him another chance, citing the importance of family and second chances. This dilemma raises questions about boundaries, responsibility, and the balance between familial loyalty and self-preservation.

Should she prioritize her own peace and well-being, or is there a moral obligation to support a struggling family member? Join the conversation as we delve into the complexities of this situation and explore the opinions of those who have faced similar challenges.

Original Post

I (24F) own a small house I worked my ass off to buy and fix up. My brother (31M) has always been a total mess with jobs and life in general.

Last year he begged to stay with me ,just a couple months, because he'd landed a good job right here in our state, super close to my house. He swore he'd save up quick and move out on his own.

I said yes but set clear rules: pay some bills, clean up, no parties, stick to the job. He never paid anything, trashed the place, had loud friends over all hours, borrowed my car without asking, and let his secret dog pee everywhere including my new rug.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

He ended up losing that job anyway, and after months of h**l, I kicked him out. Now he's homeless again, but he says he's got another job lined up in the exact same area and is crying that he needs a place to crash while he "gets stable." Swears he's changed and will follow rules this time.

I said no I can't handle that stress and damage again. He called me heartless.

Aunt and cousins are guilting me hard about family coming first and second chances. My friends say I'm right to protect my home and sanity.

[ADVERTISEMENT]