Should I Report a Homeless Man Smoking in the Building Despite the Consequences?

Are you in the wrong if you report a homeless person on your accommodation premises to security? That's the dilemma one Reddit user (19F) faced when dealing with a situation involving a mysterious individual setting off fire alarms and smoking near their living space.

The constant smell of cigarette smoke and the safety hazards posed by blocked staircases and prohibited smoking raised concerns among the flatmates. The fear of repercussions, such as being labeled a snitch or potentially causing the person to lose their place at university, added complexity to the decision-making process.

The community's responses varied, with some urging the original poster (OP) to prioritize safety and report the individual for the well-being of everyone in the building. Others emphasized the importance of following rules and regulations, especially when they involve potential fire hazards and blocked emergency exits.

The discussion touched on themes of compassion, personal safety, and the distinction between reporting for a valid reason versus merely tattling on someone. Ultimately, the thread highlighted the importance of prioritizing safety and addressing potential risks, even if it means navigating ethical dilemmas and potential social repercussions.

The consensus leaned towards taking action to ensure the well-being of all residents in the accommodation.

Original Post

I (19F) live in off-campus accommodation, and for approximately the past two weeks, I’ve been smelling cigarette smoke through my window on the first floor (I can smell it as I’m typing this.)

Today, there have been a series of fire alarms in the last half hour, and when I came up to my room after the third alarm, where I was waiting in the cold with two of my flatmates, I noticed a blanket and an umbrella in the staircase near the building’s laundry room. I’ve previously attempted to go down this staircase and was stopped because there’s a combination lock on it (my accommodation doesn’t usually use these locks to restrict access).

After a few seconds, I saw the blanket moving and then a tall guy stretching and lighting his cigarette (smoking on the property is forbidden and is highly likely the reason for the constant fire alarms). I’ve texted the flat group chat, and most haven’t responded, but the one who has said she feels unsafe and that I should lock my window before going to bed.

I know the logical thing would be to tell security—these fire alarms have been constant for the past week, and the smell of cigarettes is bad for my asthma too—but the snitch culture is HUGE where I am, and I really don’t want to be ‘that person’ because the guy hasn’t done anything to me, except for the smell and fire alarms, and I’d feel guilty if he got ousted and had to literally sleep on the streets. He may also get arrested for trespassing, which could cause him to lose his place at university (if he goes there, which he might do because he seems about my age).

This is probably very juvenile, but so far I’ve played the song ‘Home’ (it mentions home and cigarettes) so that the guy clues in that someone knows he’s there and stops smoking at least. I’m genuinely afraid that if he sees my face and finds out that I’m thinking of snitching on him, he’ll do something untoward. Yelling down to him isn’t an option—it would be very easy to figure out my exact room and location.

So, would I be the AH if I reported him to security despite knowing what this could do to him? TLDR: A homeless man near the stairwell in the flat is smoking, causing constant fire alarms and making flatmates feel slightly unsafe.

Should I report despite knowing he may be arrested for trespassing on private property, or I may be hailed as a snitch? UPDATE: There are two people (one man and one woman), and I’m pretty sure they’re doing the horizontal tango.

Addressing the ethical implications of reporting a homeless individual, Dr. Brené Brown, a researcher on vulnerability, emphasizes the importance of empathy in such situations. She suggests that understanding the underlying causes of homelessness can foster compassion rather than judgment. According to her, seeing the person as a human being first can significantly shift one's perspective. This approach aligns with the need for community support systems that address not only safety concerns but also the dignity of those in vulnerable positions.

Her insights remind us that compassion often leads to more constructive solutions than fear-based reactions.

Comment from u/Objective_Attempt_14

Comment from u/ontheleftcoast

Comment from u/Better-Turnover2783

Navigating Community Dilemmas

Dr. Laurie Santos, a psychology professor at Yale University, highlights the tension between personal safety and community responsibility. Her research on moral decision-making suggests that individuals often face cognitive dissonance when their values conflict with their instincts. She notes that reporting may lead to feelings of guilt while simultaneously serving the greater good of the community.

To reconcile these feelings, she recommends engaging in community discussions, which can foster understanding and create a more supportive environment for everyone involved.

Comment from u/ntermation

Comment from u/Sharontoo

Comment from u/frlejo

Homelessness is often accompanied by mental health challenges. Dr. John Thompson, a clinical psychologist, states that many individuals experiencing homelessness struggle with conditions like depression or anxiety, which can exacerbate risky behaviors like smoking in unsafe areas. He advises that addressing mental health needs through outreach programs can be more effective than punitive measures.

Such programs can provide resources and support to help individuals make healthier choices, ultimately improving the community's safety and well-being.

Comment from u/Professional-Tie3968

Comment from u/wesmorgan1

Comment from u/Charming_Ad_3223

Practical Solutions for Safety

From a public safety perspective, community leaders and housing experts suggest implementing designated smoking areas and outreach initiatives. According to Dr. Robert Cialdini, a noted influence researcher, creating a safe space for smoking can reduce hazards while respecting individual choices. He emphasizes the importance of clear communication and boundaries in maintaining a harmonious living environment.

For residents, this means advocating for policies that balance safety with compassion, potentially leading to healthier outcomes for both the community and individuals in need.

Comment from u/Glittering_Wish_8270

Comment from u/GhastlySunflower

Comment from u/Infinite-Cat-Peep

Dr. Sonja Lyubomirsky, a happiness researcher, points out that communal living situations can often lead to tension and conflict. She suggests that fostering a culture of gratitude and appreciation among residents can mitigate negative feelings towards others. By focusing on positive interactions, residents may feel less inclined to view their neighbors through a lens of fear or judgment.

Creating community-building events can encourage understanding and lessen the stigma associated with homelessness, making it easier to address safety concerns collaboratively.

Comment from u/angelswon

Comment from u/llmcr

Comment from u/RandomModder05

Understanding the Broader Context

Experts in urban sociology, like Dr. Eric Klinenberg, emphasize the importance of addressing the systemic issues that lead to homelessness. He argues that community engagement and resource allocation are key to preventing homelessness in the first place. His studies show that communities with strong social networks are better equipped to support individuals facing hardship.

By fostering a sense of belonging and support, residents can work together to create environments that prioritize safety and compassion, effectively reducing the need for reporting incidents like smoking.

Comment from u/tehmimikitteh

Comment from u/YaYahtzee

Comment from u/Lucky_Life5517

In addressing the dilemma of whether to report a homeless individual, it's vital to consider the long-term implications for both the individual and the community. A relationship expert noted that fostering open dialogues about safety and concerns can lead to more effective resolutions. Encouraging residents to voice their feelings without resorting to reporting can create a collaborative atmosphere.

Establishing community forums where residents can discuss their concerns and propose solutions can empower everyone involved to take a more proactive approach toward communal living.

Comment from u/Wise-Matter9248

Comment from u/Cupcake681

What's your opinion on this situation? Join the conversation!

Expert Opinion

This situation highlights the tension between personal safety and social morality that many people face. The original poster's fear of being labeled a "snitch" reflects a common psychological phenomenon called social conformity, where individuals often prioritize group norms over their own safety or well-being. Additionally, their compassion for the homeless man suggests an empathetic response that can sometimes conflict with the instinct to protect oneself and others from potential harm.

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Ultimately, navigating the complexities of reporting a homeless individual involves balancing safety with compassion. Experts from various fields agree that fostering understanding and community support is essential. As Dr. Brené Brown eloquently puts it, empathy can lead to more effective solutions than fear-driven actions. By engaging in open dialogue and creating supportive environments, communities can address safety concerns while upholding the dignity of all individuals.

Incorporating practical strategies, like designated smoking areas or community outreach programs, can enhance safety and foster a sense of belonging, leading to healthier community dynamics.