Should I Separate Finances From My Husband Over His Parents' Money Requests

Are you the jerk for deciding to separate your finances from your husband due to his continuous financial support for his parents? The original post sheds light on a nine-year relationship where the dynamic has shifted dramatically in the past year.

The OP, a saver, finds herself at odds with her husband, a spender, who has a habit of lending money to his family without much consideration for their own financial well-being. The situation escalated when the husband, disabled after a car accident, began doling out a significant sum of money to his parents, despite prior agreements and financial struggles within the household.

The comments section is buzzing with support for the OP's decision to take control of her finances and protect herself from further financial strain. Users suggest actions like separating all finances, seeking legal advice on shared debts, undergoing marriage counseling, and even considering a complete separation if necessary.

The community resonates with the OP's frustration and emphasizes the importance of financial transparency, respect, and shared responsibility in a marriage. The consensus leans heavily towards the OP not being in the wrong for prioritizing her financial stability and questioning her husband's actions and priorities.

Original Post

My husband and I have been together for over nine years, and separating our finances never occurred to me until this past year. I'm the saver, and he's the spender.

In the beginning, it didn't bother me because we had two incomes and weren't rich but lived comfortably. His family has always "borrowed" money from us but rarely pays that money back.

I personally don't lend money, not even to family, but I do not stop him from lending to his. A few years ago, my husband was in a bad car wreck and can no longer work, so I became the sole breadwinner.

He now receives disability, but that was a four-year process. During that time, we dwindled our savings to nothing and came close to losing everything.

Our debt mounted, and there was nothing I could do. When he received his back pay, I only asked him to pay off his vehicle loan, on which I've paid over 50 grand in the last few years, and to put some in savings.

He did neither. Instead, he blew the money.

He loaned over 10 grand to his family and paid nothing toward the debt we created. During this time, I was able to save some money from my paycheck, but not much, and I had plans to pay off some debts once I had enough saved.

He knew I was saving to do this. About a month ago, I noticed over 700 missing from our savings, and I asked him what happened!

He replied that he loaned it to his parents. I asked when he was going to receive it back because that money was already spent, and I needed it.

He said he didn't know when they could afford to. I blew up and lost my temper.

He didn't ask me; we didn't speak about it. He did it behind my back because he knew it would upset me, and I would say no if he asked.

We had a huge fight. I figured after that fight he would stop.

But no... Yesterday, I checked my account, and another thousand dollars was gone.

Gone where, you ask? He gave it to his parents.

I'm so mad I see red. I flat-out told him that as of today, I'm done with his parents.

I'll pay half the household bills, buy our food, and that's it. If he wants to lend all his disability to them, fine, but I'm not going to bust my ass 60 hours a week so he can keep giving our money away.

So, AITA for going to the bank, withdrawing all the money I put there, and opening a new account he doesn't have access to? He seems to think I am and says that I should want to make his parents happy.

I would like to see them happy; I just don't want to pay for that happiness.

Understanding Financial Betrayal

Financial decisions within relationships can evoke feelings of betrayal, particularly when one partner feels undermined. According to Dr. Julia White from the University of Michigan, financial betrayal can stem from unmet expectations and a lack of communication.

Research indicates that financial disputes are among the leading causes of relationship breakdowns, emphasizing the importance of transparency and mutual agreement in financial matters.

Comment from u/Trevena_Ice

Comment from u/DubiousPeoplePleaser

When one partner makes unilateral financial decisions, it can trigger feelings of insecurity and distrust. Studies in the Journal of Economic Psychology suggest that financial independence and autonomy are crucial for healthy relationship dynamics, and when these are threatened, conflicts often arise.

This highlights the importance of shared financial goals and collaborative decision-making in maintaining trust within partnerships.

Comment from u/PeanutGallery10

Comment from u/Suspicious-8388

The Role of Communication in Relationships

Open communication is essential in addressing financial disagreements. Experts recommend creating a safe space for discussing financial issues, where both partners feel heard and respected. Dr. Sarah Johnson, a family therapist, emphasizes the importance of regular financial check-ins to align on goals and responsibilities.

Research suggests that couples who engage in proactive financial discussions report higher relationship satisfaction and lower levels of conflict.

Comment from u/Ready-Replacement181

Comment from u/Fancy_Association484

Furthermore, utilizing tools like budgeting apps can facilitate these conversations by providing a clear overview of financial goals and spending habits. Studies show that technology can enhance communication by offering a neutral ground for discussions, reducing emotional triggers associated with money.

Creating joint financial plans can also reinforce cooperation and shared responsibility, fostering a sense of partnership.

Comment from u/slendermanismydad

Comment from u/Euphoric-Joke-4436

Setting Boundaries and Expectations

Establishing clear financial boundaries is crucial for maintaining a healthy relationship. Research indicates that couples who define their financial roles and responsibilities tend to experience less conflict over money. Dr. Emily Roberts, a relationship psychologist, suggests that couples discuss their individual financial values and expectations openly.

This can help create a shared understanding and reduce feelings of resentment or betrayal.

Comment from u/Own-Kangaroo6931

Comment from u/[deleted]

Additionally, couples should consider involving a financial advisor to navigate complex financial decisions. Research shows that having an objective third party can help clarify roles and expectations, ultimately leading to more constructive outcomes.

Comment from u/Altruistic_Boss_138

Comment from u/[deleted]

The Impact of Financial Stress on Relationships

Financial stress can significantly impact relationship dynamics, often leading to increased conflict. Studies in the Journal of Marriage and Family reveal that financial strain is a primary predictor of marital dissatisfaction.

Understanding the psychological impact of financial stress can help couples approach these issues with greater empathy and support for each other, fostering resilience in the face of challenges.

Comment from u/Unwanted88

Comment from u/Kanulie

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

Comment from u/November-8485

Comment from u/NinjaBabaMama

Comment from u/bumbalarie

Comment from u/HappySparklyUnicorn

Comment from u/miflordelicata

Psychological Analysis

This situation reflects the complexities of financial decision-making within relationships. It's essential for couples to engage in open communication to navigate their financial landscape collaboratively, minimizing feelings of betrayal and fostering mutual respect.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, navigating financial conflicts in relationships requires open communication, shared goals, and clear boundaries. Engaging in proactive discussions about finances can help mitigate feelings of betrayal and foster a sense of partnership.

As highlighted by the American Psychological Association, understanding the emotional dynamics behind financial decisions is crucial for maintaining healthy relationships.