Should I Split Ownership 50/50 on Garage I'm Buying Before Wedding?
AITA for refusing 50/50 ownership of a garage I'm buying with my own money before our wedding, while my fiancée already owns a half-million-dollar apartment?
Are you ready for some relationship drama? Picture this: a soon-to-be-married couple, OP (a 30-year-old man) and his fiancée (a 36-year-old woman), are facing a dilemma over ownership of a garage. They previously bought an apartment together on a 50/50 basis, but now OP wants to purchase a garage next to the building using his own money. The fiancée argues that since anything purchased after marriage becomes joint property in their country, she should have a share in the garage to prevent OP from potentially gaining all the value. However, the twist here is that she already owns an apartment worth nearly half a million dollars, solely in her name. OP is torn, feeling uncomfortable about sharing ownership of something he's buying independently just before the wedding. He's seeking advice on whether his stance makes him the villain in this scenario.
From a psychological perspective, this situation taps into fundamental aspects of human behavior such as trust, fairness, and decision-making within relationships. Issues like these often bring out unconscious biases and ingrained beliefs about gender roles, money, and power. According to Dr. Michele Gelfand, a cultural psychologist, "The way couples negotiate ownership reflects deeper cultural norms and personal values." This might explain why financial equality is such a contentious topic in many partnerships. Furthermore, Dr. Gary Chapman, a marriage counselor, emphasizes that "understanding each other's perspectives on money can significantly impact relationship dynamics." This context is crucial as OP and his fiancée consider their future together.
Original Post
Me (m30) and my fiancée (f36) are getting married in a month. We bought an apartment together earlier this year.
We both put in about the same amount of money, took out a big loan, and the ownership is 50/50. I found a garage next to the apartment building, and I'm purchasing it to have more space for us to store all our stuff.
Her argument is that if the garage increases in value, I would then be left with nothing, while the apartment is already 50/50, and the garage would be an addition to the same unit. In our country, anything you buy after marriage is joint property; what you have bought before remains your personal property.
What makes me feel uncomfortable here is that she already has an apartment that, in a couple of years, will be worth close to half a million, which will remain hers. Yet, at this moment, she wants me to put her name on a $10,000 garage that I'm paying for in full. Am I the a*****e here?
Comment from u/QuietObserver75
Comment from u/Mission-Carry-887
What do you think about this situation? Let us know in the comments.
Comment from u/ResearcherOdd2996
Comment from u/Standard-Recover8604
Comment from u/jma7400
Comment from u/SprinkleBich
Comment from u/Mermaidtoo
Comment from u/diminishingpatience
Comment from u/no_fcks_lefttogive
Comment from u/sunny_suburbia
Comment from u/user3849203
Comment from u/MarchGuilty3556
Comment from u/professorgrey99
Comment from u/Homer4598
Comment from u/Polish_girl44
Comment from u/Maker_of_woods
Comment from u/spirosoflondon
Comment from u/MmaRamotsweOS
Psychological Analysis
The situation described here really taps into the psychology of fairness and equity in relationships. It seems both parties may be grappling with the fear of being taken advantage of, which can cause tension, especially when money is involved. Open and honest communication about financial expectations and fears might help alleviate such anxieties and build trust.
Analysis generated by AI
Analysis & Alternative Approaches
Are you ready for some relationship drama? Picture this: a soon-to-be-married couple, OP (a 30-year-old man) and his fiancée (a 36-year-old woman), are facing a dilemma over ownership of a garage. They previously bought an apartment together on a 50/50 basis, but now OP wants to purchase a garage next to the building using his own money. The fiancée argues that since anything purchased after marriage becomes joint property in their country, she should have a share in the garage to prevent OP from potentially gaining all the value. However, the twist here is that she already owns an apartment worth nearly half a million dollars, solely in her name. OP is torn, feeling uncomfortable about sharing ownership of something he's buying independently just before the wedding. He's seeking advice on whether his stance makes him the villain in this scenario.
From a psychological perspective, this situation taps into fundamental aspects of human behavior such as trust, fairness, and decision-making within relationships. Issues like these often bring out unconscious biases and ingrained beliefs about gender roles, money, and power. According to Dr. Michele Gelfand, a cultural psychologist, "The way couples negotiate ownership reflects deeper cultural norms and personal values." This might explain why financial equality is such a contentious topic in many partnerships. Furthermore, Dr. Gary Chapman, a marriage counselor, emphasizes that "understanding each other's perspectives on money can significantly impact relationship dynamics." This context is crucial as OP and his fiancée consider their future together.
