Struggling with Neglect: Refusing to Care for Ill Uncle - AITA?

A 22-year-old woman with BPD and ADHD just got hit with a new kind of stress, the kind that comes with zero warning and a lot of guilt. She already works full-time, manages her own meds, and keeps up with her mental health, all while living with a father she says has neglected her for years.

Then her dad swoops in with a sick uncle and, somehow, that means she is automatically the caregiver. No conversation, no “are you okay with this,” just the expectation that she jump in because “family.” With her mom gone and no contact, she feels trapped between doing the “right” thing and dealing with the emotional fallout of being forced into a role she never agreed to.

So now she’s stuck wondering if refusing makes her the villain, or if her dad is the one unfairly dumping his responsibilities on her.

Original Post

So, I'm a 22F who was diagnosed with BPD and ADHD earlier this year. I work full-time and manage my own therapy and medications.

I live with my neglectful father since my mom is gone, and we have no contact. Recently, my dad brought in my ill uncle and expects me to care for him without even asking for my thoughts or feelings.

For context, my relationship with my dad is strained due to his neglect and lack of support. Since I was diagnosed, I've been focusing on my own well-being and setting boundaries.

Now, presented with this situation, I feel overwhelmed and conflicted. On one hand, family is important, and my uncle needs help.

However, considering my own mental health struggles and the lack of support I've received from my dad over the years, I feel it's unfair for him to suddenly expect me to take on this caregiving role. I've expressed my concerns to my dad, but he dismisses them, saying it's my duty as family.

I'm torn between feeling obligated to help and prioritizing my own mental health. So, AITA?

The emotional toll of caregiving can be particularly heavy for individuals managing their own mental health challenges.

Comment from u/gummybear_gal

Comment from u/coffeebean123

Her day-to-day reality, working full-time and managing her own BPD and ADHD, is what makes her dad bringing in her ill uncle feel especially unfair and sudden.

Adding to her dilemma is the unsupportive environment created by her father. The absence of emotional support can significantly hinder a person's ability to cope with stressors in their life. This lack of support not only affects immediate emotional health but can also have long-lasting repercussions on overall well-being. In the OP's case, her father's stringent expectations may further contribute to her feelings of obligation and resentment. This dynamic can create a toxic cycle, where the pressure to meet unrealistic standards exacerbates her emotional turmoil. It becomes essential for her to reassess her emotional landscape and consider seeking out healthier relationships that can provide the support she so desperately needs.

Comment from u/action_jackson

Comment from u/dreamer_duck22

When she tells her dad she’s overwhelmed and conflicted, he shuts it down with the “duty as family” line that basically ignores everything she’s been through.

That also echoes the fight between the older sister and the poster after she shared private screenshots without permission, across the other sisters.

Should I Have Shared Screenshots of My Conversation with My Older Sister to Our Other Sisters Without Permission?

Boundary Setting and Mental Health

Establishing healthy boundaries is vital for anyone in a caregiving role, particularly for those managing mental health concerns.

For the OP, it may be beneficial to communicate her limits to her father clearly and honestly, while also expressing how the demands of caregiving impact her mental health. This can help create a more supportive dynamic between them, where both parties feel respected and understood.

Utilizing assertive communication techniques can empower her to set those boundaries effectively, ensuring that she prioritizes her own needs while still being there for her father. Ultimately, taking these steps can lead to a healthier caregiving experience for both individuals involved.

Comment from u/skyhigh_23

Comment from u/sunny_side_up

The strained history matters here, because she’s not just juggling a sick uncle, she’s also living with the neglect she says never got fixed.

To navigate her challenging situation more effectively, the original poster (OP) can implement a structured approach to self-care and boundary-setting that is both practical and empowering. Immediate steps include identifying her feelings and writing them down, which serves as a vital exercise in self-reflection and emotional processing. This simple act of journaling not only helps clarify her thoughts but also allows her to confront and understand her emotions in a more tangible way.

In the short term, over the next 1-2 weeks, she might consider scheduling regular check-ins with a therapist. These sessions can be invaluable in reinforcing her coping strategies and providing her with tools to manage stress more effectively. Additionally, she could benefit from setting aside time for activities that bring her joy and relaxation, creating a much-needed balance in her life.

Finally, in the longer term (1-3 months), she could explore support groups specifically designed for caregivers. Engaging with others who share similar experiences can provide a sense of community and understanding, further enhancing her emotional resilience. This connection with others will not only validate her feelings but also offer practical advice and encouragement as she navigates her caregiving journey.

Comment from u/stormy_seas_99

Comment from u/pizzaparty_88

By the time the comments start pointing out how her father’s lack of support fuels the resentment, the whole situation turns into a real AITA showdown.

How would you handle this situation? Let us know in the comments.

Comment from u/mellow_mindset

Comment from u/whimsical_wolf

The challenges faced by the young woman in this narrative are deeply rooted in her ongoing battle with mental health issues, particularly BPD and ADHD. Her father's neglect only exacerbates her situation, leaving her with the daunting task of caregiving for her ill uncle without the necessary support. This scenario not only reveals the critical need for social support systems but also emphasizes the importance of establishing healthy boundaries. Such boundaries are vital for anyone, particularly those managing mental health conditions, as they navigate the complexities of responsibility and self-care in high-stress environments.

He might be the problem for expecting free caregiving on top of everything she’s already carrying.

Next, see what happened when a son bought a house and the mom considered moving out, despite guilt.

Should I Feel Guilty for Moving Out After Son Buys Us a House?