Tiger Parent Rips Up Daughter's Book For Not Sticking To Enforced Summer Reading Schedule

A dad put his 10-year-old daughter on a strict schedule during her summer break to teach her about discipline and hard work. OP felt that his daughter spent too much time reading books and not enough on her studies.

OP expressed frustration as an immigrant parent at seeing his daughter spend so much of her time on a "good but ultimately useless" hobby. He believed his daughter used her hobby as an excuse to neglect her studies.

OP refused to reward his daughter's "bad behavior" by declining to purchase a book series she had requested. His punishment didn't work, as his sister surprised his daughter with the book series when she visited.

OP's objection to his daughter's reading habit reached a crescendo when she failed to follow the exacting schedule he set for her during summer break. OP wakes his daughter up at 7:30 in the morning.

Her tasks include music practice, piano lessons, advanced reading of the syllabus, and writing mathematical tables. OP stated that if his daughter completed the tasks one after the other, she should be free around noon.

He felt that was enough time for his daughter to read or engage in whatever sparked her interest for the rest of the day. Recently, his wife reported that their daughter didn't follow the schedule and spent her time with her nose buried in the book her aunt bought for her.

OP was furious. He went to his daughter's room and tore her book to pieces.

throwaway677995

He threw the tatters in the bin to punish his daughter. She immediately cried when she saw what OP had done.

throwaway677995

Understanding Parental Expectations

The concept of 'tiger parenting' reflects a stringent parenting style that emphasizes high achievement and obedience, often at the cost of emotional well-being.

According to Dr. Dan Siegel, a renowned child psychiatrist, "While high expectations can drive success, they can also create anxiety and resentment in children." Research supports that such methods may lead to children struggling with self-esteem and the ability to pursue their true interests, ultimately causing a disconnect between parents and children.

She talked to her mom, who explained why OP's punishment was justified.

throwaway677995

The next day, OP received a call from his sister. She questioned why OP tore the book apart. She called OP a horrible person and said he traumatized his daughter with his unjust punishment. OP refused to believe that his disciplinary measures were extraordinary.

throwaway677995

Emotionally, tearing up a child's work can be interpreted as a profound breach of trust, undermining the child's sense of safety and validation.

Studies show that children thrive in environments where they feel supported and valued, rather than in situations where their efforts are harshly criticized.

Building a nurturing relationship involves encouraging autonomy and allowing room for mistakes, as this fosters resilience and a love of learning.

OP's punishment wouldn't teach his daughter to follow him. She would fear him but never respect him.

AurynTD

His daughter excels in school, but OP still doesn't count that as hard work. If he doesn't see her spending 12 hours a day studying, it doesn't count.

throwaway677995

The Impact of Pressure on Child Development

Research from developmental psychology highlights that excessive pressure can lead to burnout and disengagement from activities that were once enjoyable.

In fact, a study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that children who feel forced to meet high expectations exhibit higher levels of anxiety and lower levels of intrinsic motivation.

When children are encouraged to engage in their interests freely, they are more likely to develop a lifelong love of learning and creativity.

Does OP realize that his daughter is a 10-year-old trying to enjoy her summer break?

AurynTD

Not even the most dedicated academics spend 24 hours a day, seven days a week studying.

ScissormanCT

Practical recommendations include fostering open communication and encouraging children to express their feelings about academic pressures.

Parents might consider implementing a more collaborative approach to education, where children have a say in their learning experiences.

Engaging in discussions about interests and passions, rather than solely focusing on performance metrics, can create a more supportive family dynamic.

"Your child is not an investment portfolio. She is a whole person with her own interests."

UnaIsTiredYaDig

What does OP do during his day off? Does he also follow a strict schedule that teaches discipline and hard work?

Silver_Took32

What are the chances of OP being one of those people who believe mental health is an excuse used by lazy people? If he doesn't change the way he treats his daughter, he will drive her to a mental breakdown or cause a plethora of issues that will affect her well into her adulthood.

His parenting style will also impact their relationship once his daughter is an adult. She will cut him off while he's too busy crediting his strict parenting style for her success.

Parents dream of having a kid like OP's, yet here he is destroying the things she holds dear.

Optimal-Novel-6095

OP would sooner burn books than apologize to his daughter.

mesembryanthemum

His sister is right; OP did traumatize his kid.

_higglety, throwaway677995

If he doesn't change his parenting style, she will cut him and his wife out of her life as soon as she can.

joyfall

They will only ever hear of her achievements from other people. If she allows them to be a part of her life, she will hide the most important parts of herself.

SatisfactionNo1753

Psychological Analysis

This incident illustrates the conflict that can arise when parental expectations clash with a child's autonomy. It’s essential to recognize that children's emotional well-being is just as important as their academic performance.

Balancing these aspects can significantly improve family dynamics and foster healthier development in children.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Overall, the balance between guidance and autonomy is crucial in parenting.

Understanding and adapting parenting styles to suit a child's emotional needs can lead to healthier relationships and more successful outcomes in the long run.