First Responder Recalls Final Moments of Man Who Died Trapped in Utah’s Nutty Putty Cave

Utah’s Nutty Putty Cave has a way of turning “just one more squeeze” into a nightmare you cannot crawl out of. John was only 26 when a wrong turn in the dark turned his body into a human cork, wedged upside down in a crevice that was barely bigger than a backpack.

It wasn’t just the rock that made it brutal, it was the timing and the chaos around it. Josh got out first and sprinted for help, then dozens of volunteers and emergency personnel spent 27 hours trying to solve a problem that physics kept refusing to cooperate with. Even Brandon Kowallis, who crawled in to reach John, described the moment as John slipped in and out of consciousness, hallucinating angels and demons.

And the scariest part is how quickly a “near the turnaround” mistake became a final moment.

John was just 26 when he died

Family handout

The Wrong Turn That Changed Everything

At some point during the trip, John mistakenly took a different path, believing he was heading toward the turnaround. Instead, he entered an unmapped, dead-end crevice measuring just 10 by 18 inches. He became wedged upside down, his head pointing downward and his body folded into the rock.

Josh was the first to realize the danger and rushed out of the cave to find help. What followed was a 27-hour rescue effort involving dozens of volunteers and emergency personnel. Despite their expertise, the responders faced nearly impossible conditions: the space was too tight to pull John out and too deep to break apart quickly.

Josh realized something was wrong after John’s wrong path, then bolted out of Nutty Putty Cave to fetch help.

It's also worth noting the role of group dynamics in such situations. The presence of friends and family can intensify risk-taking through peer pressure and the diffusion of responsibility, a phenomenon where individuals feel less personal accountability because the responsibility is shared among the group (Darley & Latané, 1968). This could have influenced Jones's decision to venture into the cave.

John was trapped for 27 hours

Family handout

By the time Brandon Kowallis got to John, the rescue had already stretched into a 27-hour ordeal.

“It Was Already Too Late”

Explorer and YouTuber Brandon Kowallis, who took part in the rescue, described the scene in a blog post. By the time he reached John, the trapped man was slipping in and out of consciousness and experiencing vivid hallucinations of “angels and demons.”

“As I wormed my way in, I felt my feet touch something soft, which ended up being John’s feet. I felt them move and immediately lifted my feet and worked my way horizontally into the crack,” Kowallis recalled.

“After stabilizing myself by jamming my body into a narrower section of the crack, I began speaking to John, asking him how he was and introducing myself. There was no response.”

Soon after, Kowallis heard what he described as “a deep, gurgling breath,” likely the result of John’s lungs filling with fluid. John began kicking frantically, a desperate final attempt to free himself.

Realizing how impossible the rescue would be, Kowallis and others started preparing for a long and painstaking process. “There was a request to take the radio down to John so that his family could say some words to him,” he said. “I think it was his father, mother, and wife who spoke to him, telling him that they loved him and were praying for him, and that his father had given him a blessing. His wife mentioned a feeling of peace, that everything would be OK.”

She spoke to him for several minutes before rescuers resumed their work. But shortly afterward, Kowallis was asked to check for signs of life.

“I didn’t hear a distinct heartbeat, only some ruffling, fluttering sounds that were probably a result of me shaking as I tried to steady myself in an awkward location. I then jammed my hand between the rock and pressed as far up his torso as I could go to feel for breathing. I didn’t think I felt anything.”

Kowallis reported his findings to the paramedic, who squeezed in as far as possible and confirmed the worst. John Edward Jones was pronounced dead at 11:52 p.m.

It’s like the boyfriend who commented on his girlfriend’s neck during necklace shopping, and she snapped.

The cave has since been sealed off

Family Handout

John’s hallucinations, “angels and demons,” hit hard as Kowallis felt his feet and tried to reposition himself in the crack.

John Edward Jones' tragic story in Nutty Putty Cave serves as a stark reminder of the allure and peril that comes with adventure-seeking. His decision to explore the cave reflects a common drive among thrill-seekers who are drawn to intense and novel experiences. The cave's twisting, narrow passages are not just a playground for adrenaline junkies; they can also become death traps. The psychology behind sensation-seeking behaviors explains why individuals like Jones are often willing to take risks in pursuit of excitement. While such traits can lead to unforgettable adventures, they also carry significant dangers, particularly in environments as treacherous as Nutty Putty Cave. Jones' fate underscores the need for awareness and caution in the face of nature's unpredictable challenges.

Why His Body Was Never Recovered

Authorities determined that attempting to remove John’s body would be too dangerous for rescuers. Instead, they made the decision to leave him where he was and permanently seal Nutty Putty Cave. Using controlled explosives, the entrance was collapsed to prevent future tragedies.

Today, a memorial plaque stands at the site to honor John’s life. His story continues to serve as a sobering reminder of the risks associated with extreme caving.

In 2016, the events were adapted into the biographical drama The Last Descent, bringing John’s ordeal to a wider audience. For many, it remains one of the most haunting examples of how quickly an adventure can turn into a fight for survival — and how, despite the best efforts of rescuers, some situations remain beyond human control.

Then came that “deep, gurgling breath,” and John started kicking frantically like the next second might be the way out.

The first responder's vivid recollection of the tragic incident involving John Edward Jones underscores the profound and enduring impact such traumatic experiences can have on those who witness them. The harrowing nature of the event, where Jones became trapped in the narrow confines of Nutty Putty Cave, illustrates just how critical emotional resilience can be in the aftermath of such crises. Responses to trauma can vary significantly among individuals. While some may find themselves grappling with post-traumatic stress disorder, others might experience a form of post-traumatic growth, emerging from adversity with a newfound perspective on life. This dynamic highlights the complex interplay between trauma and emotional recovery, particularly in high-stakes environments like cave rescue operations.

The tragic incident at Nutty Putty Cave underscores the complex interplay of personality traits, group dynamics, and coping mechanisms when confronted with extreme circumstances. The harrowing experience of John Edward Jones and the subsequent rescue efforts reflect not only the physical dangers inherent in such environments but also the psychological toll on everyone involved. As thrill-seekers venture into the cave's perilous twisting passageways, they must also grapple with their own resilience and character under pressure. The emotional aftermath for both the victims and the responders serves as a stark reminder of the lasting impact of such tragedies, offering crucial insights into human behavior and our capacity to endure adversity.

John’s last move was trying to escape a mistake that never should have been a mistake at all.

Before you judge, read about the plane stranger who escalated after accusing him of hitting.