Guy Makes His Brother Sleep In The Basement Because He Sleepwalks, But His Roommate Says He's An AH For This

We're back again with another Reddit post here and you guys know that we love to look at Reddit posts from the AITA thread a lot. That's what we are here with today and this time it's uploaded by a guy who wants to know if he's in the wrong for making his brother sleep in the basement.

Now, this sounds terrible right off the bat, and after you get to the end of this post it really might not seem any better, but we still wanted to dive in and show you this post fully in depth. So with that, we're looking at a post that was submitted by a man who wants to know if he's wrong for having his brother sleep in the basement.

He speaks about the condition that his brother deals with and how he's having him sleep in the basement as a result of this but his roommate thinks this is quite rude. The brother sleepwalks and can cause damage in the middle of the night or hurt himself, which is what OP doesn't want happening and it's why he's asking him to sleep in the basement.

Let's dive in and see what the roommate has to say, take a look at OP's original post, and also see what people had to say in the comments section.

OP starts off by explaining who he is and what his situation is with his roommate and brother.

The little brother essentially got kicked out of the house and is now living with OP and his roommate.

This is when he gets into details on the agreement and then he brings up the main issue at hand here.

Understanding Sleep Disorders and Their Impact

Dr. Linda Foster, a sleep psychologist at Harvard Medical School, emphasizes that sleepwalking is often linked to deeper psychological issues, such as anxiety or unresolved trauma.

Her studies indicate that individuals who experience sleepwalking may be attempting to escape from stressors in their waking life.

This can complicate household dynamics, especially when others are affected by the sleepwalker’s actions, as seen in this case.

We can definitely understand how this is an issue but also his brother could really hurt himself.

This is when OP decided to come up with a plan on how they could still live with him but without him putting holes in their walls.

The roommate is actually the one saying that OP is not right for doing this at all and that he's TA here.

Behavioral observations suggest that the roommate's concerns reflect a broader fear of unpredictability, which can lead to anxiety in shared living situations.

Research indicates that living with someone who has a sleep disorder may heighten stress levels for other household members, leading to potential conflict.

If OP feels that this is safe and his brother doesn't ming then maybe there's really not problem here.

He's right about the renovations and if his brother isn't staying there long then there's no reason to do all of that.

OP seems to have been a little defensive over the whole thing of his roommate talking about the decision he made.

Navigating Roommate Conflicts

Studies in the Journal of Social Psychology reveal that clear communication and conflict resolution strategies are paramount in resolving disputes among roommates.

Implementing a structured plan for nighttime safety can reduce anxiety for all parties involved, such as designating safe sleep zones or using alarms to alert others.

Engaging in open discussions about each person's fears and needs can foster a collaborative approach to conflict resolution.

Many people said that if the brother doesn't mind then neither should they but maybe that's not the right things to think.

south3y

We have to agree here that OP's brother really does need to talk to a doctor or something because this doesn't seem normal.

Moon-Queen95

It seems like most people here think that OP is in the wrong and he's TA for thinking his roommate is out of line.

extremelycrabby

Addressing these issues through mediation can be beneficial. It’s essential for both parties to articulate their concerns and find common ground.

Utilizing resources like a therapist or mediator can help facilitate these conversations, promoting understanding and empathy.

He could hurt himself anywhere honestly but it's best to make sure that he's within view if he is.

anthrois9246

I really hope that if anything, OP will get some help for his brother and medical advice on his sleepwalking.

Lopsided_Respect_158

People seriously had a lot to say here and most of them told OP that he's the one who is TA here and he's obviously not keeping an eye on his brother. If anything he really should get his brother some medical help and his parents are not that great for leaving him to fend for himself essentially.

Psychological Analysis

This scenario highlights the stress that living with someone who has a sleep disorder can cause, often leading to misunderstandings and heightened anxiety.

Recognizing these factors is crucial for developing effective strategies to maintain a harmonious living situation.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Ultimately, understanding the psychological underpinnings of sleep disorders can pave the way for compassionate coexistence.

Research suggests that addressing these dynamics proactively can lead to improved relationships and reduced anxiety in shared living environments.