Confessing My Feelings to Friend After Giving Dating Advice: AITA?

Some people don’t recognize a favor, and this story is basically the emotional version of that. A 27-year-old woman tried to help her best friend, Sarah, after Sarah asked for dating advice. It sounded simple: be straightforward, tell the guy how you feel, and move from there.

Except the coworker rejected Sarah and then started avoiding her, which made everything feel way heavier. And while Sarah was dealing with the fallout, the OP was stuck feeling guilty, confused, and, somehow, also developing feelings for Sarah. Then she finally confessed, and the conversation went from “supportive friend” to “betrayed.” Now the friendship is awkward, tense, and full of questions about what she should have kept to herself.

Here’s the full story of how one bit of relationship advice turned into a complicated confession.

Original Post

So, I (27F) have this close friend, let's call her Sarah (26F). Sarah recently had a crush on a coworker, and she asked me for dating advice.

I suggested she be straightforward and tell him how she feels. However, things took a turn when the coworker rejected Sarah and started avoiding her.

Feeling guilty for the outcome, I found myself developing feelings for Sarah amidst the chaos. It was a mix of emotions - guilt, attraction, and confusion.

I debated whether to confess my newfound feelings, unsure of how Sarah would react. One evening, I mustered the courage and revealed my emotions to Sarah.

The conversation was tense, and Sarah seemed taken aback. She mentioned feeling betrayed that I would keep my feelings hidden while advising her on relationships.

Now our friendship feels strained, and there's an awkwardness between us. I care about Sarah deeply, but I can't shake off these feelings that have surfaced.

I'm torn between regretting the confession and wanting to be honest with Sarah. So, AITA for opening up about my feelings after giving Sarah dating advice that didn't end well?

I'm grappling with the aftermath of my actions and need some clarity from an outside perspective.

This story illustrates how easily good intentions can lead to emotional fallout. The OP's advice to Sarah to be direct with her crush, while well-meaning, didn't account for the complexity of unreciprocated feelings. When Sarah faced rejection, it not only strained her relationship with her crush but also put the OP in a difficult position. The OP's confession of feelings afterward adds another layer of tension, turning a supportive gesture into a potential source of conflict.

The moral gray area here is palpable. Should OP have kept her feelings private to maintain the friendship? Or was it fair to express her emotions, given the circumstances? Readers are likely divided on whether the OP's honesty was admirable or misguided.

Comment from u/Carpe-Diem24

Comment from u/TacoTuesday88

Comment from u/SunflowerSeedz

The whole mess starts when Sarah asks the OP for advice about her coworker, and the “just be honest” plan quickly backfires.

That’s when the coworker’s rejection and sudden avoidance leave Sarah hurting, and the OP is left wrestling with guilt instead of closure.

Like the friend who asked for crush advice and then fell for the same coworker, this AITA spirals into a friendship triangle.

The Ripple Effect of Advice

What stands out in this situation is how one piece of advice can ripple through multiple relationships. The OP’s encouragement for Sarah to be direct seems straightforward, but it highlights the unpredictability of love and friendship. Sarah’s rejection didn't just hurt her; it also inadvertently impacted her friendship with the OP, who now feels vulnerable and possibly guilty for the role she played.

This story resonates with many because it touches on the universal experience of navigating feelings within friendships. Readers might find themselves wondering how they would handle similar dynamics, especially when emotions are involved. It's a poignant reminder that even well-intentioned advice can lead to unexpected consequences.

Comment from u/RainbowSkies72

Comment from u/JellyBeanDreamz

Meanwhile, the OP’s feelings for Sarah keep growing, so the confession stops being harmless honesty and turns into a landmine.

After Sarah says she feels betrayed for being kept in the dark, the friendship shifts from awkward crush recovery to full-on tension between them.

Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section.

This story serves as a reminder of the delicate balance between friendship and romantic feelings.

The Bigger Picture

This situation reveals how quickly good intentions can spiral into emotional turmoil. The OP's well-intentioned advice to Sarah put both women in a difficult position when the crush didn't reciprocate feelings, leaving Sarah feeling rejected and the OP grappling with guilt and newfound attraction. By confessing her feelings, the OP hoped to be honest, but that honesty backfired, making Sarah feel betrayed at a sensitive moment. It’s a classic case of how navigating friendship and romantic feelings can lead to unexpected and messy outcomes.

Now everyone’s wondering if the OP was honest, or if she just detonated the one relationship she was trying to protect.

After Sarah’s coworker rejected her and avoided her, read what happened when you confessed anyway in AITA for Giving Dating Advice to Friend and Confessing My Feelings?.