Redditor Uses Conspiracy Theories To Derail His Dad's Political Arguments And Wins Over The Internet

Having a debate over differences in opinions can be perfectly healthy and even enjoyable. However, sometimes these sorts of conversations can become heated and, at times, nasty.

Recently, Reddit user u/doubled-or-nothing shared a story in the AITA (Am I The A**hole?) subreddit about his experience. The OP explained that his dad loves to engage in political discussions, which can often become heated.

The OP believes his dad doesn't even care about most of the topics he brings up; he just likes to argue and start fights with family members. The Redditor says he has tried to steer clear of these conversations, but then his dad gets upset that he is not participating.

The OP has been looking for ways to redirect these discussions for a while since they almost always result in hurt feelings. He says he read a story online about how if someone argues a conspiracy theory, you should come back with something even more far-fetched, so the OP decided to try and implement this theory with his dad.

When the OP's dad started talking about how the Chinese government had partnered with Obama to "make up" climate change, the Redditor had the perfect comeback. He began to discuss his "new theory" about how the federal government created a tornado machine to use on people who vote Republican.

The OP's dad was so flabbergasted by how ridiculous the theory was that he decided to stop the conversation altogether. The OP's plan worked!

So, when the OP's dad tried to make a toast over Christmas dinner to "the death of Planned Parenthood," the OP had to think of something to put his dad in his place and clear the tension at the table. He said, “Oh, thank God you mentioned it; I have to tell you this news I learned.”

He then began talking about how Planned Parenthood doesn't actually perform abortions but removes human uteruses and replaces them with dog ones. The OP's mom was not impressed with his comments and said he needs to take people's political views more seriously.

She said the OP was making himself look "dismissive at best and insane at worst." Keep scrolling to see how people reacted.

The OP asked if he is an a**hole for acting like a conspiracy theorist to get out of political arguments with his dad.

Reddit/doubled-or-nothing

He explained that his father loves to have political discussions, which can often become heated.

Reddit/doubled-or-nothing

The OP says he's been looking for ways to redirect these conversations with his dad.

Reddit/doubled-or-nothing

The Psychology of Conspiracy Theories

Conspiracy theories often serve as a coping mechanism for individuals grappling with uncertainty and fear. Research from the Journal of Social Psychology indicates that belief in conspiracy theories can provide individuals with a sense of control and understanding in chaotic situations. In this case, the Redditor's use of conspiracy theories to derail his dad's political arguments may reflect a desire to regain control over a contentious topic.

Additionally, engaging in conspiracy theories can offer a sense of belonging to like-minded individuals, further reinforcing these beliefs and behaviors.

The Psychology Behind Conspiracy Theories

Engaging in conspiracy theories often stems from a need to find meaning in chaotic or uncertain situations.

Dr. Karen M. M. Dagnall's research highlights that individuals who feel a lack of control may gravitate toward these theories as a way to make sense of their world.

This behavior reflects a deep psychological need for certainty, especially in times of crisis.

The Redditor's dad was "flabbergasted" when his son began responding to his arguments with far-fetched conspiracy theories.

Reddit/doubled-or-nothing

At Christmas dinner, the OP's dad tried to make a toast to "the death of Planned Parenthood."

Reddit/doubled-or-nothing

But the OP's mom says he needs to take people's political views more seriously.

Reddit/doubled-or-nothing

Moreover, cognitive dissonance plays a significant role in the persistence of conspiracy beliefs. According to research by Dr. Leon Festinger, when individuals encounter information that contradicts their beliefs, they may experience psychological discomfort, leading them to dismiss or distort conflicting information. The Redditor's reaction to his father's political arguments may be a defense mechanism to alleviate this discomfort and maintain cognitive consistency.

Understanding these psychological dynamics can shed light on why individuals gravitate toward conspiratorial thinking, especially in emotionally charged discussions.

The Redditor's use of conspiracy theories to derail political arguments exemplifies a common coping mechanism to navigate uncomfortable discussions.

Research indicates that humor and absurdity can serve as effective tools for diffusing tension in contentious conversations, as highlighted in studies published in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships.

However, this approach can also alienate those who may not share the same perspective.

Here's how people reacted.

Reddit/deleted user

NTA.

Reddit/Scryb_Kincaid

We need more examples!

Reddit/AMPenguin

Strategies for Navigating Political Discussions

Engaging in political discussions can be challenging, particularly when differing beliefs lead to heated arguments. Research indicates that employing active listening and empathy can significantly improve the quality of these conversations. For the Redditor, practicing active listening could facilitate a more constructive dialogue with his father, allowing both parties to feel heard and respected. As Dr. William Doherty, a family therapist, states, "Empathy is the cornerstone of effective communication, especially in conflict situations." This approach is further emphasized by Dr. Michele Gelfand, a cultural psychologist, who notes, "Understanding the perspective of others can bridge divides and foster healthier discussions."

Understanding Defense Mechanisms in Arguments

Defense mechanisms often come into play during heated discussions, as individuals seek to protect their beliefs and identities.

Dr. Anna Freud's research on defense mechanisms suggests that humor and sarcasm can serve as coping strategies to mitigate anxiety in confrontational situations.

This behavior is particularly evident in the Redditor's approach to political debates, showcasing how humor can provide a sense of emotional distance.

"The real MVP."

Reddit/deleted user

"My hero."

Reddit/goeatacactus

"Insufferable."

Reddit/abyssalcrisis

Additionally, framing discussions around shared values can help bridge the divide between differing opinions. Research suggests that focusing on common ground can reduce hostility and foster more productive conversations. By identifying areas of agreement, the Redditor may find it easier to engage with his father in a way that encourages understanding and reduces conflict.

Ultimately, these strategies can help both parties navigate their differences more effectively, promoting healthier family dynamics.

However, while employing humor can provide temporary relief, it may also hinder meaningful dialogue and understanding.

Research shows that effective communication often requires vulnerability and openness, as discussed in studies from the Journal of Communication.

Without these elements, conversations can devolve into mockery rather than constructive discourse.

"Oh, that's just how he is."

Reddit/laarg

"Go all out."

Reddit/redeye1140

"You should talk more about the lizard people."

Reddit/chaotic_cutie

Practical Recommendations for Effective Communication

To foster healthier discussions, individuals should practice active listening and validate opposing viewpoints.

Encouraging open dialogues where all parties feel heard can facilitate better understanding and reduce tensions.

Moreover, incorporating humor appropriately can lighten the mood without undermining serious conversations, creating a balance between levity and respect.

A religious theory.

Reddit/79Freedomreader

"You're showing him by example what a numb-nuts he is."

Reddit/awake_receiver

"These are the rules."

Reddit/romper_el_dia

He "doesn't exist."

Reddit/voidscreaming

"Your thoughts?"

Reddit/badaboom

What's your take on this situation? Do you think the OP is wrong for how he's been dealing with his father, or is he just trying to do the right thing by keeping the peace?

We would love to hear your opinions on this. You can share your thoughts with us in the comment section.

Psychological Analysis

This situation highlights the complexities of engaging in contentious discussions, particularly around sensitive topics like politics.

It's important for individuals to recognize their own emotional responses and seek more constructive ways to communicate their viewpoints.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, the use of conspiracy theories in discussions reflects deeper psychological needs for control and understanding.

According to the American Psychological Association, fostering open dialogue and effective communication strategies is essential for navigating complex conversations.

Ultimately, balancing humor with respect can lead to more constructive interactions and mutual understanding.

Psychological Analysis

This situation illustrates the complexities of family communication, particularly when differing beliefs lead to conflict. The Redditor's strategy of using humor to deflect serious discussions may reflect deeper insecurities about engaging in contentious topics with his father.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Conspiracy theories often arise from a desire for control and understanding in uncertain times. Recognizing the psychological mechanisms at play can help individuals navigate contentious discussions more effectively. By employing active listening and focusing on shared values, families can foster healthier dialogues, even in the face of significant disagreements.