Dealing with a Puppy Roommate: Setting Boundaries on Chewing Behavior

A 28-year-old woman moved in with her friend, and it took about five minutes for the “adorable puppy roommate” phase to start feeling like a personal attack.

Max, the friend’s energetic little chewer, has been going after her shoes, her bags, and even her favorite throw blanket, like her stuff is the only thing on the menu. OP tried to talk it out, kept things calm, and asked for basic boundaries and supervision, especially after Max destroyed a pair of expensive shoes.

Now OP is stuck balancing friendship drama with the fact that her belongings keep getting demolished.

Original Post

I (28F) recently moved in with my friend, who has the most adorable puppy named Max. Max is energetic, playful, and loves to chew on things.

For background, I'm a bit of a neat freak and I like to keep my belongings in pristine condition. Ever since moving in, I've noticed that Max has taken a liking to chewing on my shoes, bags, and even my favorite throw blanket.

I've tried speaking to my friend about training Max not to chew on my things, but my friend seems to brush it off as just normal puppy behavior. Last week, I came home to find Max had completely destroyed a pair of expensive shoes that I absolutely loved.

I felt upset and frustrated, so I calmly asked my friend to keep Max away from my belongings and to supervise him more closely. However, my friend got defensive and said I was overreacting.

They claimed that Max is just a puppy and doesn't know any better. They refused to take any responsibility for the damage caused by Max.

I don't want to strain my friendship over this, but I also don't think it's fair for me to constantly replace my items because of Max's chewing habits. So AITA for asking my puppy roommate not to chew on my belongings?

Comment from u/pizza_lover121

Comment from u/gamer_gal55

Comment from u/throwaway_mystery

The moment Max shredded those expensive shoes, OP stopped treating it like “puppy chaos” and started treating it like a roommate issue.

a veterinary behaviorist, setting boundaries is crucial in shared living situations with pets.

Comment from u/coffee_addict23

Comment from u/theatre_fanatic17

Comment from u/nature_lover99

Instead of agreeing to keep Max away from OP’s stuff, her friend got defensive and doubled down on the idea that chewing is just normal.

It’s the same kind of clash as the AITA fight over expecting a disinterested family to join a dream vacation.

Addressing issues as they arise can prevent misunderstandings and foster a collaborative approach to managing the puppy's behavior.

Comment from u/bookworm_girl87

Comment from u/music_junkie28

Comment from u/animal_lover123

When OP asked for more supervision and clearer rules, the conversation shifted from training to blame, and nobody wanted to own the damage.

Animal training expert consistency is key in addressing chewing behavior.

Incorporating mental stimulation through puzzle toys or interactive games can help prevent boredom and destructive behavior.

Comment from u/reddit_addict99

So now OP is wondering if she’s being unreasonable for not wanting to constantly replace shoes, bags, and blankets because Max keeps targeting them.

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

Integrating guidance on managing a puppy's behavior is crucial for a harmonious living situation.

This situation highlights a common struggle in shared living arrangements, especially when pets are involved. The original poster's need for boundaries stems from her personality traits—like being a "neat freak"—which can clash with her friend's more relaxed view of pet behavior. This defensiveness from the friend may indicate a lack of awareness about the responsibilities that come with pet ownership, underscoring the importance of open communication and mutual respect in maintaining both friendships and household harmony.

If Max keeps chewing her stuff and her friend keeps brushing it off, OP may realize she needs a different living setup.

Want another family conflict, read about the AITA case where a woman rescheduled a family vacation because of her job.