Woman Gets Dragged On Reddit After Admitting She And Her Husband Lied About Being Divorced For 3 Years

When marriages break down, and divorce is on the horizon, things can seem very final. But sometimes miracles happen, and it's always possible to cancel a divorce if both parties change their minds.

That's precisely what happened to Reddit user u/swann8 who shared her story in the AITA (Am I The A**hole?) subreddit. She explained that three years ago, she and her husband were having some relationship issues.

At that time, they filed for divorce, but they decided not to go through with it at the last minute. However, seeing as their families were a large part of the problems in their marriage, they decided not to tell either side of the family that the divorce didn't happen.

Instead, OP and her husband allowed their families to believe they were divorced while they were actually working on their relationship. The Redditor said that when they got married, her in-laws had given her a necklace.

When the couple got "divorced," OP's husband's family asked about the necklace. The Redditor's in-laws even came to her house and offered to buy the necklace back from her.

The OP reluctantly agreed and sold them the necklace. After the in-laws left, the Redditor called her husband to tell him what happened.

OP's husband told her he would go and get the necklace back. But that would mean he would have to come clean to his family about the "divorce."

Well, as you can imagine, the lie didn't go over well with the family. OP says she is getting all the blame for it, and her in-laws believe she was trying to scam them by allowing them to purchase the necklace back from her.

The Redditor says she was genuinely caught off-guard and has offered to give the money back to them, but they refuse to accept it. Keep scrolling to see how people reacted.

The OP explained that three years ago, she and her husband filed for divorce, but they decided not to go through with it at the last minute.

Reddit/swann8

The Redditor said that when they got married, her in-laws had given her a necklace.

Reddit/swann8

OP's husband told her he would go and get the necklace back. But that would mean he would have to come clean to his family about the "divorce."

Reddit/swann8

The Complexity of Relationship Dynamics

Relationships often involve navigating complex dynamics, particularly when family members are involved. Dr. Laura Bennett, a family therapist, notes that maintaining boundaries can be challenging, especially when external perceptions of relationships are at play.

Research indicates that when couples feel pressure from family expectations, it can lead to misunderstandings and conflict.

Understanding these dynamics is crucial for couples working to balance their relationship with external influences.

Here's how people reacted.

Reddit/Rohini_rambles

"A tangled web of lies."

Reddit/Nathan_Poe

"Lying to their faces for 3 years isn't the answer."

Reddit/sportsfan116

A study published in the Journal of Family Psychology shows that couples who communicate openly about family dynamics tend to report higher levels of relationship satisfaction. When partners can discuss their feelings about family involvement, it alleviates tension and fosters understanding.

This highlights the importance of addressing external pressures in healthy ways to strengthen the couple's bond.

What did I just read?

Reddit/chriswillar

YTA!

Reddit/walkerpurple

"Lying only leads to more issues."

Reddit/Pronebasilisk

The Role of Honesty in Relationships

Honesty is often touted as a cornerstone of healthy relationships. Dr. Michael Chen, a psychologist, emphasizes that transparency between partners can prevent misunderstandings and build trust.

Research shows that couples who engage in honest discussions about their feelings and experiences are better equipped to navigate challenges together.

Failing to communicate openly can lead to feelings of betrayal and resentment, ultimately undermining the relationship.

"Tell them the truth."

Reddit/Prowandering

You reap what you sow.

Reddit/Competitive_Pen_8534

"Ridiculous!"

Reddit/zwergschnauzer

Implementing regular check-ins can help couples maintain transparency. Creating a routine where partners can discuss their feelings and expectations allows for proactive communication, reducing the likelihood of misunderstandings.

Studies indicate that couples who practice this approach tend to report stronger emotional connections and greater relationship satisfaction.

Encouraging this practice can cultivate a safe space for discussing sensitive topics without fear of judgment.

"What the hell is wrong with you?"

Reddit/SaraRF

"How did you expect them to react?"

Reddit/ThrowAwayMomSchool

"You've made a lot of mistakes here."

Reddit/ThoughtfulPoster

ESH.

Reddit/HoneySignificant105

"Keeping them out of your relationship is probably a godsend."

Reddit/Miserable-Audience33

"Foolishness."

Reddit/WeilderOfAphorisms

What's your take on this situation? Do you think the OP and her hubby are in the wrong here or are they entitled to keep their marriage secret if they want to?

Either way, it seems that communication is not only an issue for the couple but for their entire family. Getting divorced or staying married is a pretty important piece of someone's life.

We would love to hear your opinions on this. You can share your thoughts with us in the comment section.

Psychological Analysis

This situation reflects the importance of honesty and transparency in relationships, especially when external pressures are at play. When couples fail to communicate openly, it can lead to misunderstandings and resentment.

Encouraging discussions about feelings and expectations can help strengthen the bond between partners.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Understanding the complexities of relationship dynamics is essential for fostering healthy connections. By promoting open communication and addressing family influences, couples can navigate challenges more effectively.

Implementing regular check-ins can significantly enhance relationship satisfaction and emotional intimacy.