Best Friend Asks For Godmother, Then Admits She Wants Built-In Childcare
When a heartfelt ask turns into an unexpected expectation, lines start to blur.
Some people don’t recognize a favor, they just treat it like a subscription they can renew whenever they want. This one starts with a long, warm friendship, then flips into something messier the second the “meaningful” request gets attached to childcare.
A friend asks to be made a godmother, and at first it sounds sweet. But the conversation quickly reveals a bigger agenda: built-in babysitting coverage, unlimited availability, and guilt as the fine print. OP tries to be gentle, sets boundaries, and offers what she can, while her friend keeps assuming the role automatically comes with shifts.
And once the word “godparent” turns into a demand for free time, the friendship starts to crack.
It opens with a long friendship and a request that sounds meaningful, but already feels complicated.
RedditShe is clear about her feelings and sets a boundary early, even while trying to be gentle and appreciative.
RedditThe tone shifts as the conversation moves from hurt feelings to clear assumptions about babysitting and availability.
Reddit
This is where the stakes are raised, with responsibility framed as a moral obligation rather than a choice.
Reddit
She tries to meet in the middle, offering limited support while standing firm on the role itself.
Reddit
Calling someone a godparent does not automatically sign them up for babysitting shifts or guilt trips.
Reddit
Once expectations feel transactional, the meaning of the role starts to blur.
Reddit
The frustration here centers on expectations and consent, especially when parenting plans start involving other people by default.
Reddit
Parenthood comes with reality checks, and outsourcing them to friends is not part of the job description.
Reddit
It cuts to the core of the issue. The role being asked for is not the one being named.
Reddit
It points out the quiet leap from honorary role to lifelong responsibility that never got spelled out.
Reddit
Once the actual duties are laid out, it becomes obvious how much was being assumed without discussion.
Reddit
The question here is not about intent, but about expectations that were never aligned in the first place.
Reddit
It underlines how much of this conflict comes from mixing up meaning, paperwork, and expectation.
Reddit
That line about “still wanting a life” keeps coming back, and every time it does, it lands a little sharper.
Reddit
It points out how easily expectations grow when definitions are never clarified.
Reddit
A sharp reminder that one person’s idea of freedom does not automatically come from another person’s time.
Reddit
Free babysitter is not a perk that comes bundled with a sentimental title.
Reddit
It nudges the conversation toward shared responsibility, not defaulting to the most convenient person.
Reddit
Planning a support system after the fact is where a lot of this tension seems to come from.
Reddit
When the original meaning is spelled out, the mismatch between the ask and the expectation becomes hard to ignore.
Reddit
The godmother request lands like a compliment, but OP already senses the babysitting angle behind it.
When OP tries to set a boundary, her friend responds with the kind of “but I still want a life” logic that makes everything feel transactional.
The hurt feelings shift into scheduling expectations, because now the friend is treating OP’s time like it’s part of the parenting plan.
Once the duties get spelled out, it becomes obvious the role was never discussed, it was assumed, and that’s what really stings.
This story sits at the crossroads of loyalty, honesty, and self-awareness. Some people see godparenthood as a promise to step in no matter what, while others view it as a symbolic bond, not a practical safety net. It also raises a harder question about friendship. Is support about showing up in ways that feel right to you, or stretching yourself to meet someone else’s needs? How would you have handled this moment, and where would you have drawn the line? Share it with someone who has strong feelings about boundaries and chosen family.
Nobody wants to be guilted into babysitting just because they agreed to be called a godmother.
Still think childcare should be “just handled”? See what happened when a roommate demanded payment for cat allergy treatment in this AITA.
