Redditors Pass Their Verdict On A Woman Who Wants To Give Up Her Nephew To A Foster Home

Death is a terrible thing, and it hits hard on the loved ones who are left behind.

A family tragedy turned into a painful custody dilemma when a 32-year-old woman found herself caring for her 12-year-old nephew after both of his parents died. What started as temporary support quickly became a question of whether she could, or should, raise him herself. With elderly parents, autism, no desire for children, and little comfort around kids, she said the situation has been overwhelming.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

Now the boy’s future is still undecided, and her choice could mean foster care. Read on.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

The Headline

The Headlineu/maybeasshole88
[ADVERTISEMENT]

This May Make Me Seem Heartless

This May Make Me Seem Heartlessu/maybeasshole88
[ADVERTISEMENT]

My Sister-in-Law Died in an Accident

My Sister-in-Law Died in an Accidentu/maybeasshole88

I've Never Been Good Around Children

I've Never Been Good Around Childrenu/maybeasshole88

Ever Since the Accident...

Ever Since the Accident...u/maybeasshole88

My Parents Are Elderly and...

My Parents Are Elderly and...u/maybeasshole88

This Is Not the Best Outcome, But...

This Is Not the Best Outcome, But...u/maybeasshole88

I Haven't Told Him My Decision

I Haven't Told Him My Decisionu/maybeasshole88

They'll Distance Themselves

They'll Distance Themselvesu/maybeasshole88

I Can't Take Care of Him

I Can't Take Care of Himu/maybeasshole88

And Now to the Much-Awaited Question...

And Now to the Much-Awaited Question...u/maybeasshole88

The post was upvoted 12.5K times and received more than 5K comments. Here are some of the verdicts passed by the Redditors.

One commenter thought the family needed to talk this through first.

1. Have You Actually Talked to Your Parents?

1. Have You Actually Talked to Your Parents?overseas-mango

This also echoes the Reddit AITA about refusing to share baby fund savings with a sibling in need.

2. The Likelihood He'll Be Adopted Is Low

2. The Likelihood He'll Be Adopted Is LowFritemare

3. Some of the Problems Can Be Addressed

3. Some of the Problems Can Be Addressedstarchy2ber

4. Teenagers Are Very Rarely Adopted, and That's a Fact

4. Teenagers Are Very Rarely Adopted, and That's a Factbizianka

5. There Is No Correct Answer for Me

5. There Is No Correct Answer for MeZOE_XCII

6. The Alternative Isn't Always Better

6. The Alternative Isn't Always BetterFew-Afternoon-6276

7. Yes, It Will Be Tough, But You Need to...

7. Yes, It Will Be Tough, But You Need to...Ornery-Barracuda-134

8. Have Any of These People Offered Any Help?

8. Have Any of These People Offered Any Help?Kris82868

9. Lots of Information Needed, and the OP Supplied It

9. Lots of Information Needed, and the OP Supplied ItBeneficialDark1662

10. It Won't Be Easy, But You Should Step Up

10. It Won't Be Easy, But You Should Step Uppanzer22222

11. You Have an Unrealistic Idea of What It's Like

11. You Have an Unrealistic Idea of What It's LikeOldGrumpyLady

12. You've Made Up Your Mind Already

12. You've Made Up Your Mind AlreadySquirrelBowl

13. One of the Few Posts That I'm Stunned By

13. One of the Few Posts That I'm Stunned ByPotemkinDickinson

14. I'm Not Going to Vote

14. I'm Not Going to Votefairie88

15. Your Parents Should Take Care of Him

15. Your Parents Should Take Care of HimIntelligent-Bread777

16. Your Choice Is Yours

16. Your Choice Is Yoursthepepsyy

17. It's Really a Hard Case, But...

17. It's Really a Hard Case, But...Prestigious_Net_383

18. There Are Always Ways to Accommodate Yourself

18. There Are Always Ways to Accommodate YourselfMagnoliaProse

19. Another Info Needed, and the OP Replied

19. Another Info Needed, and the OP RepliedCreativeAirQuotes

20. Not Everyone Is Meant to Be a Parent

20. Not Everyone Is Meant to Be a Parentfireandping

Here is an update the Redditor included after all was said and done.

Death is a terrible thing, and it hits hard on the loved ones who are left behind. Some Redditors understood the story from the OP’s perspective, some were against her decision, and the rest were just on the fence.

What are your thoughts about this story? Drop your replies in the comments section below.

Now the whole family is waiting to see what she decides.

For another brutal family split, see how someone handled inheritance after leaving a troubled sister less.

More articles you might like