Man Asks Roommate To Reduce Cat Count Due To His Allergies And Agreed Limit Of "Only" Three Cats

It started with a deal that sounded simple on paper: OP and his best friend were sharing a small, no-lease apartment, paying the landlord cash, splitting rent and chores like adults. OP even brought his own important detail to the table, he has asthma and cat allergies.

But the roommate treated that detail like a suggestion. OP began with three cats in the home, and after they moved in together, his roommate kept adding more cats without discussing it. By the time OP had a bad asthma attack and asked for a hard limit of only three cats, the apartment had ballooned to seven, turning every day into a breathing problem.

Now OP is stuck wondering if he should have trusted his roommate at all, because the “friend” part of the arrangement is doing a lot of damage.

OP lives with his best friend in a small apartment without a lease, paying the landlord in cash. Despite his asthma and cat allergies, he agreed to this arrangement for housing.

They agreed to split rent and chores evenly, but his friend brought in four more cats without discussing it, even though he knew OP had allergies and asthma.

The situation between OP and his roommate highlights the common friction that can arise in shared living environments, especially when it comes to personal boundaries and responsibilities regarding pets. The article points out that moving in with a friend can lead to misunderstandings, especially if expectations about pet ownership are not clearly defined from the start.

This scenario illustrates how essential it is for roommates to openly discuss their needs and limitations to foster a respectful living arrangement. By addressing these differences, they can work towards a solution that accommodates everyone's well-being, ensuring that the joy of cohabitation does not turn into a source of constant frustration.

OP had a bad asthma attack and asked his roommate to keep only three cats. The roommate blamed OP for moving in despite being allergic to cats.

He originally had three cats, but now there are seven, worsening OP's allergies and asthma, despite claiming to care about OP's health.

When OP agreed to live there despite his allergies, he thought the “three cats” idea was already baked into the plan.

The moment OP asked for only three cats after a bad asthma attack, the roommate should have treated it like a hard rule, not a suggestion.

Moreover, the presence of allergies in a shared living situation can complicate these dynamics further.

Studies have shown that allergies can lead to significant physical discomfort, and individuals may feel justified in requesting changes to their living environment.

This underscores the importance of communication in negotiating pet responsibilities that accommodate everyone's needs.

Encouraging open discussions about health concerns can facilitate a more collaborative living environment.

He becomes defensive about his extra cats, disregarding the impact on OP's health.

OP is questioning whether it's okay to have seven cats in a small apartment and if the daily smell of cat urine and feces is tolerable.

Then his roommate quietly brought in four more cats, right after knowing OP’s asthma was a real issue.

Instead, the roommate kept bringing in extra cats, turning the apartment into a seven-cat situation that directly flared up OP’s symptoms.

Speaking of roommate-style tensions, this is like the WIBTA fight over announcing a pregnancy at a best friend’s baby shower.

Like the guy asking his girlfriend for a 15-minute airport ride, this turned into an argument.

Setting Agreements on Pet Responsibilities

Encouraging roommates to articulate their responsibilities and preferences can lead to more equitable arrangements.

Utilizing written agreements can further solidify these expectations and help ensure accountability.

OP asked his roommate to remove the extra cats he brought in beyond their agreed-upon limit of three.

Both parties share the blame.

Reddit

After OP suffered a bad asthma attack and asked for the limit again, the roommate blamed him for moving in at all.

When OP points out the obvious problem, the roommate flips it back on him, blaming OP for moving in while continuing to ignore the cat count agreement.

OP and his roommate are both to blame here. It's unfair to expect someone to give up their pets, but having seven cats in a small space is excessive. While asking someone to part with their furry friends is difficult, everyone's health should be considered.

Perhaps they could find a middle ground, such as finding new homes for some of the cats or taking measures to help OP with his allergies. Ultimately, the roommate needs to realize how the extra cats affect OP and try to find a solution that works for both of them. It's all about fairness and respect for each other's well-being.

It's unfair to ask someone to part with their pets.

Reddit

Having seven cats is excessive.

Reddit

With seven cats in the apartment and OP’s health clearly worsening, the roommate’s “I care about you” attitude starts sounding fake.

And with the rent split and chores still “even,” OP is left stuck in the same small space, asking whether seven cats is even remotely reasonable.

Additionally, conversations about pet counts can reveal deeper issues related to commitment and responsibility.

The cats are his.

Reddit

In the realm of shared living, the delicate balance between personal needs and shared responsibilities often becomes a point of contention, as illustrated by the current dilemma faced by the individual with allergies. This case exemplifies how failing to communicate effectively can lead to frustration and discomfort, particularly for those with health concerns like asthma.

Open dialogues about pet ownership and its implications for all residents are crucial. By acknowledging and addressing each other's needs, roommates can cultivate a living space that not only respects individual health requirements but also enhances the overall cohabitation experience. The path to a harmonious living environment lies in mutual understanding and respect, which are vital in navigating the complexities of shared households.

Now OP is stuck wondering if he’s the bad guy, or if his roommate just never meant “only three cats” in the first place.

Wait, it gets worse, check out the AITA fight over a secret holiday recipe.

He might be happier finding a new place before the apartment turns into a full-time allergy trap.

Want more holiday boundary drama? Read why someone refused to share their secret recipe.