Roommate Neglects Puppy: AITA for Setting Boundaries on Pet Care?

Some people don’t recognize a favor, and this roommate situation is proof. One woman moved in expecting shared bills, shared life, and maybe some casual dog cuddles. Instead, she walked into a Max problem, and it only got worse the longer she stayed.

Sarah, her college friend, adopted a puppy named Max, then immediately started working long hours and disappearing into her social life. While Sarah was out, Max was stuck alone, whining, hungry, and having accidents. OP tried talking it out, but Sarah brushed it off like Max would just “be fine.” Then Sarah asked to bring in another puppy for a few days, and OP watched Max get sidelined even harder.

Now OP is drawing a line about pet care and refusing to allow more dogs until Max is taken care of, and Reddit is split on whether she’s protecting Max or being controlling.

Original Post

I (27F) recently moved in with my college friend, Sarah (25F), who adopted an adorable puppy named Max. When Sarah first got Max, she was very attentive, taking him on walks, feeding him properly, and making sure he had his vaccinations.

However, things have taken a turn since I moved in. Sarah often works long hours and spends most of her free time socializing, leaving poor Max alone in the apartment for hours.

I've found him whining, hungry, and with occasional accidents in the house. For background, I grew up with dogs and firmly believe in responsible pet ownership.

I've tried talking to Sarah about the importance of consistent care for Max, but she brushes it off, saying he'll be fine. It breaks my heart to see Max neglected, so I've started taking over his care when Sarah's not around.

I take him for walks, ensure he's fed, and give him the attention he needs. The other day, Sarah asked if her friend's puppy could stay in our apartment for a few days.

I agreed, thinking she'd step up her care for both pups. But to my dismay, she's neglected Max even more since the new puppy arrived.

She spends all her time fawning over the guest puppy, while poor Max is left alone in a corner. I've had enough.

I told Sarah that she needs to prioritize Max's well-being, and until she can commit to proper care for him, I won't allow any other dogs in our apartment. She got defensive, accusing me of overstepping and being controlling.

But I stand by my decision. So, Reddit, am I the a*****e for standing up for Max's well-being and refusing to let her bring in another puppy without proper care for him?

Research highlights that neglecting a pet's needs can lead to behavioral issues, creating a stressful environment for both the animal and the owner.

Creating a shared pet care schedule can help ensure that all roommates are on the same page about responsibilities, fostering a healthier living arrangement for everyone involved.

Comment from u/MusicNerd87

Comment from u/CozyBlanket23

Comment from u/HikingAdventures22

OP first thought Sarah would step up once she moved in, but Max kept getting left alone while Sarah prioritized her own schedule.

American Humane suggests that potential pet owners should consider their lifestyle, living situation, and ability to care for an animal before making the decision to adopt. Failure to do so can lead to situations like the one described, where one roommate feels overwhelmed by the responsibility of another's pet.

This situation could have been mitigated by a thorough discussion about pet care responsibilities before adopting Max, ensuring both roommates were aligned on expectations.

Comment from u/PizzaLover99

Comment from u/TechieGamerGirl

Comment from u/MountainMama

After OP found Max whining, hungry, and having accidents, she tried bringing up consistent care, and Sarah basically waved her off.

This is also like the AITA about splitting savings with a boyfriend who keeps reckless spending.

To improve this situation, Sarah should consider professional training or behavioral consulting to better understand Max's needs, ultimately enhancing both their living situation and the puppy's well-being.

Comment from u/BookwormGal

Comment from u/CoffeeAddict84

Comment from u/BeachExplorer777

The real blow came when Sarah brought a guest puppy idea to the table, and suddenly Max was stuck in the corner again.

By addressing the issue directly and collaboratively, roommates can create a shared plan for pet care that respects everyone's boundaries and ensures Max receives the love and attention he deserves.

Comment from u/FoodieForever

That’s when OP shut the door on any other dogs in the apartment, and Sarah flipped from “he’ll be fine” to accusing her of being controlling.

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

The Reddit post illustrates how neglecting these elements can lead to significant tension and discontent among roommates.

The situation with the roommate neglecting her puppy highlights a common issue in shared living spaces: the clash between personal freedom and responsibility. It seems like Sarah may be struggling with the commitment that comes with pet ownership, which often requires a level of emotional investment that she might not be prepared for. This can lead to defensiveness when confronted, as it touches on feelings of guilt or inadequacy about her choices. Meanwhile, the original poster's decision to set boundaries reflects a protective instinct, not just for the puppy, but also for her own well-being in a challenging living situation.

Max deserved better than being the roommate who gets ignored, and now OP is asking if she’s the villain for refusing to watch it happen.

Same messy boundaries vibe, read about a friend who got backlash after offering parenting advice.