Roommate Takes My Makeup: AITA for Confronting Her and Making Her Cry?

AITA for confronting my roommate about taking my makeup, leading to a surprising turn of events that left her in tears and me questioning her motives?

Sophia

Published in Interesting
25 May 2025

Roommate Takes My Makeup: AITA for Confronting Her and Making Her Cry?

It started with a concealer, the kind of small, boring item that should never turn into a roommate feud. OP (22) lives with her roommate (22), a cordial, religious girl who they barely talk to, mostly surviving on polite hellos and awkward silence. But when OP’s concealer vanishes, reappears in her makeup bag next to the lipstick she used that morning, then disappears again, the mystery stops being funny fast.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

OP is convinced she knows where she left it, and she’s not the type to misplace things for days. She even notes where it was after the first incident, then uses it that night, only to wake up to an empty spot in the next morning routine. The complication is that OP has a reason to be suspicious, and her roommate has a reason to feel accused, especially since their whole living situation is already tense and distant.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

And once OP starts checking her roommate’s room, the “where did my concealer go” question turns into a full-on confrontation.

Original Post

I (22 F) have lived with my roommate (22 F) for 1.5 years. We met through a mutual friend, and we go to the same college, but we have different majors.
I can't say we get along; we don't talk much. Sometimes, we even go days without saying anything but hello.
We're very different. She's somewhat religious and is very cordial in all her interactions (she sort of acts like a 40-year-old woman even though she's 22). However, I am not religious at all and am more laid back with my friendships. We quickly realized that we're too different to be friends, so we kept our relationship distant and civil.
This Monday, I got up early to get ready for class. For context, I always keep my makeup in a bag that's sitting on my vanity, and it's right in front of the door to my room.
As I got up to do my makeup, I realized I couldn't find my concealer ANYWHERE. I turned every corner because I had bought the damned thing recently.

Twenty minutes later, I decided I didn't have time for it and was going to be late to my lecture. I put on some lipstick (this is an important detail to the story) and put the lipstick in my makeup bag.
When I got back, I immediately went into my room to continue my search for my concealer, and to my shock, it was in my bag of makeup, right next to the lipstick I used in the morning. This struck me as odd because if it had been there the whole time, I would have noticed it when I picked up the item literally next to it.
I brushed it off because I can be a little inattentive sometimes. That night, I went out with some friends and used the concealer for my makeup.

When I got back home, I made sure to note where I put the concealer so I wouldn't waste time looking for it the next morning. I even made a comment about it to my boyfriend.
The next morning, I woke up, and the stupid concealer was gone AGAIN! This time, I was certain I KNEW where I had put it.
Now, this is where things get tricky. I went to check my roommate's room to see if it was there by chance.

It's important to note that I have permission to enter her room because we keep some appliances, like the vacuum cleaner and the iron, in her closet because it's much bigger than mine. So I went into her room, and I didn't have to look for long.
Her makeup was lying on the floor, and among them were two of my items: my concealer and a Fenty powder foundation I thought I had lost a month ago. I didn't immediately jump to the conclusion that they were mine because she could have had the same items.
BUT! I did check the shades they were in, and they do not match her skin tone at all. Both items were in my shade.
I decided that I should record this in case she decided to lie about it later, so from this moment on, I recorded everything that happened. I talked with my friends, and even though some of them suggested I just take the makeup and lock my stuff in a safe (my door is broken and doesn't lock), I told them it just rubbed me the wrong way to take things from someone's room.
I didn't want to stoop to her level. So I deliberately left the makeup, thinking maybe she had borrowed it and forgot to return it later (which I would have been fine with!).

The following day and a half, I didn't mention anything about the makeup, but I was getting paranoid. I have a fear of strangers breaking into my home (I have recurring nightmares), and this whole deal threw me for a loop.
I started recording my room at night and when I wasn't there (I even caught her walking into my room and using my micellar water, but she later told me about it candidly. I told her it was fine since it happened once).
Wednesday night, I told her that I couldn't find my concealer anywhere and that I suspected our stuff got mixed up, and I asked her to look in her room for me. She said she didn't know about it and claimed that she had never seen it, and that she uses a different brand.

I told her to look for me since I've been searching for it for a couple of days and I had bought it recently. This whole interaction was friendly, and I didn't insinuate that I had seen it in her room.
I still wanted to see if she would return it by herself. Well, she didn't.
On Friday, I decided that I had had enough. I confronted her about it and told her that I had seen it in her room. I wasn't even being rude; I just said that I needed it and that I last saw it in her room.

She got mad and told me that if the concealer was all I cared about, she would buy one for me. I told her I didn't care about the money, just that I knew it was still in the house and I didn't want to buy another when I knew where the original was.
She got really upset and kept repeating that she would buy me one if that was all I cared about. I finally had enough of her nonsense and told her to forget it and that I could certainly pay for it myself.
I went into the kitchen to make myself some tea, and she started crying in her room and basically throwing a tantrum. I don't feel bad, really.

I got really paranoid because of her actions, and I don't have a single doubt that it was my stuff in her room because I recorded everything. I'm just confused why someone would take makeup that doesn't even match their skin tone??
And why not return it later when I gave her every chance to? AITA?

Setting boundaries is crucial in shared living situations, as it helps maintain respect and personal space.

Comment from u/No_No_Yes_Silly_5850

[ADVERTISEMENT]

Comment from u/lexi2222222222

[ADVERTISEMENT]

That first “how is it in my bag next to my lipstick?” moment is what makes OP second-guess everything about that roommate who barely speaks to her.

Furthermore, the concept of emotional intelligence plays a significant role in how individuals navigate conflicts over boundaries.

In this case, developing emotional intelligence can help the individual confront their roommate in a way that promotes understanding rather than conflict, potentially leading to a more amicable resolution.

Comment from u/blonde1psp

Comment from u/Vivid-Farm6291

Conflicts, such as arguments over personal belongings, can strain relationships significantly.

Comment from u/cassowary32

Comment from u/EcoFeministWitch

When the concealer is gone again the next morning, OP decides she has to stop guessing and actually investigate.

To effectively confront the roommate about the makeup situation, it can be helpful to approach the conversation with empathy and clarity. Using 'I' statements can help express feelings without blaming the other person, fostering a more productive dialogue.

For example, saying, 'I felt upset when I noticed my makeup was missing,' conveys emotion without casting blame, which can lead to a more open exchange.

It also echoes the roommate who refused to limit shower time and fought over the water bill.