Roommates Overnight Guest Dilemma: AITA for Objecting?
AITA for objecting to my roommate's guest? Opinions divided on whether it's a double standard or valid concern, with judgments based on appearances and age differences.
There are few things more awkward than sharing a bathroom with someone who treats “overnight guests” like it’s a revolving door. This college apartment drama went from normal roommate life to full-on tension when the OP started clocking the pattern: her roommate, Melissa, keeps bringing the same guy, Chris, to stay the night.
Chris is 34, unemployed, and has a very specific vibe, tattoos, piercings, and a DUI from last year, which is exactly why the OP says he makes her uncomfortable. The twist is, the OP’s also not single, her boyfriend stays over too, but they’re in a committed relationship and he’s a grad student at the same college, unlike Chris who is just a “friend” or, basically, FWB with no real connection to campus.
Now it’s turned into a double-standard fight, and the OP is wondering if she’s the asshole for drawing a line.
Original Post
I live in a college apartment with a roommate, let's call her Melissa. We are both 21F.
We have a 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom place. Melissa has a habit of bringing a guy, we'll call him Chris, to spend the night.
They aren't dating, just "friends", or I guess you could say FWBs. This guy is 34, has no job, and looks like a gangster (tattoos, piercings, etc.) I looked him up and he got a DUI last year.
His presence makes me uncomfortable to be honest. To be fair, my boyfriend also spends the night regularly, and is around the same age (33).
However, my boyfriend is a grad student at our college, and we are in a committed relationship for over a year. Chris is a random guy with no connection to our college, who she is not even officially dating.
Melissa says I have a double standard, but I think this is a different situation entirely. AITA?
Comment from u/Santa_Hates_You
Comment from u/sootfire
Comment from u/locoles
Comment from u/Living_Cranberry_890
Comment from u/Rtarara
Comment from u/Extra_Commercial2409
Comment from u/ConflictGullible392
Comment from u/Several_Razzmatazz51
Comment from u/EvaSirkowski
It’s giving the same energy as the AITA poster stepping down from hosting duties after years of planning.
Comment from u/ILoveRizzo
Comment from u/Consistent-Star5745
Comment from u/tinybrrrfriend35637
Comment from u/Soft_Remote_1511
Comment from u/AcanthisittaPlus5047
Comment from u/Maleficent-Yam4650
Comment from u/lemon_charlie
Comment from u/SickSwan
Comment from u/Miserable-Result-922
Comment from u/kingofmymachine
Comment from u/CoconutCaptain
Melissa’s “friends” excuse for Chris does not exactly help when the OP is already uneasy about his DUI history.
The OP tries to explain the difference, pointing out her boyfriend is a grad student and her relationship is official, not casual.
Then Melissa fires back with the double standard accusation, even though the apartment is still the same shared space.
With Chris showing up overnight again, the OP has to decide whether her discomfort matters or if she’s expected to just accept it.
What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.
If Melissa wants a free-for-all guest policy, she might want to start by not calling OP’s boundaries “the problem.”
For another “split the item or refuse” blowup, see the AITA fight over refusing to split a cherished family heirloom bracelet.
