Should I Ask My Best Friend to Choose: Me or Her Boyfriend?

Laura used to be the person OP could always count on, the one who showed up for weekly movie nights like it was a sacred tradition. Then she met Alex at work, and suddenly those cozy, two-person plans started disappearing into thin air.

Now OP is watching her best friend get slowly replaced in real time, from movie nights turning into once every two months to Laura constantly texting or checking her phone during their rare hangouts. When OP finally has a rough day and needs her, Laura is too busy with Alex. And when OP tries to recreate the old vibe this weekend, Laura already has plans with him.

This is the moment when a friendship feels like it’s being traded for a boyfriend, and OP is stuck deciding whether to make it an ultimatum.

Original Post

So I'm a 27-year-old woman, and my best friend, let's call her Laura, is 26. We've been inseparable since college, and I've always been there for her through thick and thin.

Recently, Laura started dating this new guy, Alex, whom she met at work. At first, everything seemed fine, and I was happy for her.

Quick context: Laura and I used to have a tradition of weekly movie nights, just the two of us, where we would catch up and h**g out. It was something special to us.

However, ever since Laura started dating Alex, she has been spending less and less time with me. Our movie nights have turned into once every two months, and even then, she's constantly texting Alex or checking her phone.

I've tried talking to her about it, but she brushes it off, saying she's just really into him. Last week, I had a tough day and needed to talk to someone, but Laura was too busy with Alex.

I felt really hurt and lonely, like I've been replaced as her go-to person. This weekend, I texted Laura to h**g out, just the two of us like old times, but she said she had plans with Alex.

Feeling frustrated and neglected, I'm considering asking Laura to choose between her new boyfriend and our friendship. I miss the bond we had, and I feel like I'm losing my best friend to this new guy.

So, Reddit, would I be the a*****e if I give her an ultimatum?

This scenario is a classic example of the tension that often arises when a friend enters a serious relationship. The OP feels neglected as Laura’s focus shifts to Alex, and it's easy to see why that would sting. After all, they used to have weekly movie nights, and now those cherished moments have dwindled. It’s not just about feeling sidelined; it’s about the fear of losing a friendship that has likely provided emotional support for years.

Readers likely empathize with OP’s struggle because it taps into a universal fear: will love always trump friendship? The emotional stakes are high here, as asking Laura to choose could shatter their bond, creating a rift that may not be repairable.

Comment from u/CrazyCatLady82

Comment from u/MovieBuff247

Comment from u/BeachBum99

That weekly movie night tradition with Laura and OP used to be their thing, until Alex walked in and the schedule started collapsing.

The Consequences of Ultimatums

OP’s consideration of asking Laura to choose between her and Alex introduces a significant moral dilemma. Ultimatums can feel like a last resort, and in this case, they could backfire spectacularly. If Laura feels pressured to make a choice, she might resent OP for putting her in that position. After all, relationships evolve, and asking someone to abandon a new love could breed bitterness.

Moreover, it raises questions about the nature of friendship. Is it selfish for OP to demand this kind of loyalty? It’s a fine line between wanting to maintain closeness and risking a fracture that might turn both women against each other.

Comment from u/AdventureSeeker555

Comment from u/PizzaLover23

Comment from u/MusicLover86

When OP tried to talk about being neglected and Laura brushed it off as “just being really into him,” the tension stopped being subtle.

This is similar to a friend being asked to choose between their friendship and dating the poster’s ex.

Why This Strikes a Chord

This story resonates with many readers because it reflects a common life experience: friends drifting apart due to romantic relationships. The OP's feelings of neglect are relatable, making it easy for others to weigh in with their own stories of friendship and love. The Reddit community's debate likely stems from personal experiences, with some advocating for OP to voice her feelings while others caution against sounding controlling.

The fact that Laura’s relationship with Alex began at work adds another layer of complexity. There’s an unspoken understanding that workplace romances can be tumultuous, which might make OP’s feelings more poignant as she worries about being sidelined.

Comment from u/TechGeek55

Comment from u/SunnyDays12

Comment from u/Bookworm333

The real gut punch came when OP needed Laura last week, but Laura chose Alex instead, leaving OP feeling lonely and replaced.

The Grey Areas of Friendship

In friendships, there's often a grey area that complicates matters, especially when romantic interests come into play. OP’s desire for more attention from Laura isn’t inherently wrong, but it does bring up questions about self-centeredness versus genuine concern. There’s a delicate balance between wanting to be prioritized and recognizing that relationships can shift and change.

Additionally, this scenario sheds light on the importance of communication. While OP feels neglected, it’s unclear if she’s expressed her feelings to Laura. If she hasn’t, that might just exacerbate the situation. The community responses likely reflect a mix of empathy and caution, highlighting the many shades of friendship dynamics.

Comment from u/CoffeeAddict88

Now OP is texting again for “just us like old times,” and getting shut down with “plans with Alex,” which is where the ultimatum idea starts to simmer.

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

The Takeaway

This story illustrates the complexities of friendship when romantic relationships enter the picture. OP’s dilemma raises important questions about loyalty, communication, and the fear of losing a cherished bond. How do you think OP should approach this situation? Should she confront Laura, or is it better to give her space to enjoy her new relationship?

What It Comes Down To

The situation presented in this article highlights a common struggle when friendships face the challenges of new romances. OP's feelings of neglect stem from the drastic change in her relationship with Laura, who seems more focused on Alex than their once-cherished movie nights, illustrating how easily dynamics can shift when a partner enters the picture. OP's consideration of an ultimatum reflects a deep-seated fear of losing an important bond, yet it also raises the risk of alienating Laura further. This scenario serves as a reminder of the delicate balance between wanting to maintain closeness and respecting the evolution of friendships.

If OP forces the choice between her and Alex, she might not just lose the boyfriend, she might lose the friendship too.

Want another ultimatum showdown, like the sister who had to pick her boyfriend or friendship? Read what happened when she forced the choice.