Should I Have Told My Friend Before Dating Her Ex?

A 28-year-old woman refused to mention one tiny, devastating detail, and now her friendship with Emily is hanging by a thread. OP and Emily have been close since college, the kind of friends who show up for breakups, late-night talks, and emotional damage control.

Emily dated Alex last year, but they split six months ago. OP supported Emily through the fallout, and then, somehow, she and Alex started connecting. They decided to date, but OP still has not told Emily, because she’s scared Emily will feel hurt, betrayed, or angry.

Now the question is whether OP’s silence protects her friendship, or blows it up before Emily even gets a say.

Original Post

I (28F) have been friends with Emily (28F) since college. Last year, Emily dated Alex, but they broke up six months ago due to conflicting priorities.

Throughout their relationship, I supported Emily and comforted her during tough times. Recently, I started developing feelings for Alex.

We had a genuine connection and decided to start dating. However, I haven't told Emily about our relationship yet.

I'm afraid she'll be hurt or angry, considering their history. I value our friendship, but I also care for Alex deeply.

So, AITA for not disclosing my relationship with her ex-boyfriend?

Caught in a Friendship Crossfire

This situation showcases the tightrope we often walk between friendship and romance. The OP's decision to date Alex without informing Emily raises immediate questions about trust and loyalty. It's easy to see why the OP felt conflicted, especially if she believed her feelings were genuine. However, not informing Emily adds an underlying tension that can fracture their friendship.

The emotional stakes are high for all three parties involved. Emily might feel blindsided and betrayed if she finds out, and Alex could be caught in the middle, unsure of which side to take. This dilemma is a classic example of how love can complicate relationships, turning friends into foes when the lines blur.

Comment from u/SleepyDragonfly

Comment from u/coffee_queen22

Comment from u/Pizza_and_Pasta

OP comforted Emily during the breakup, so it feels extra brutal that Emily might learn she’s now dating her ex from someone else.

The Dilemma of Honesty vs. Happiness

The OP's predicament taps into a common debate around honesty in relationships. On one hand, pursuing happiness is a natural human inclination, but at what cost? If the OP truly believes Alex is a better match for her than he was for Emily, does that justify keeping this from her friend? Readers are divided, with some supporting the OP's right to seek her own happiness, while others argue that transparency is essential in any friendship.

This moral grey area reflects deeper societal norms about loyalty and the ethics of dating an ex. It’s fascinating to see how people’s values around friendship and romance clash in the comments, revealing just how subjective these situations can be.

Comment from u/sky_higher

Comment from u/SunnySide_

Comment from u/jupiter_rising

The six-month gap between Emily and Alex’s split makes OP’s timing look suspicious, even though feelings can’t be scheduled.

It’s also like the years-long secrecy in AITA for secretly dating his ex for years, then going public.

Once OP and Alex “had a genuine connection,” the whole dynamic shifted from best-friend support to best-friend betrayal territory.

The Unspoken Rules of Dating Exes

This story highlights the unspoken rules that govern friendships and romantic relationships. While some might argue it’s perfectly acceptable to date a friend's ex, others see it as a blatant betrayal. The OP's choice to keep it under wraps suggests a fear of backlash, which speaks volumes about the weight of these unspoken rules. Emily could feel that her past relationship is being disrespected, and that could lead to resentment.

This conflict sheds light on how friendships can be tested by romantic interests. The OP's actions could either lead to a new love or a shattered friendship, and many readers are curious about how this story will unfold. What happens when the desire for connection outweighs the fear of hurting someone you care about?

Comment from u/TheCuriousCat

Comment from u/MoonlitMeadow

Comment from u/cherry_blossom22

If Emily finds out after the fact, the friendship that started in college could turn into an all-out blame game with Alex stuck in the middle.

As the OP navigates her feelings for Alex, it's crucial to consider the emotional fallout that may ensue. If Emily finds out about the relationship, the potential for heartbreak and anger could be immense. This situation serves as a reminder that our decisions in love don’t just affect us; they ripple outward, impacting those around us. The OP might have been enthralled by her newfound feelings, but the consequences could be dire.

This isn't just about two people dating; it's about a friendship that could be irrevocably changed. The tension between wanting to pursue one's happiness and the responsibility we have to our friends adds layers to this scenario that many readers can relate to. It's a delicate balance that can easily tip, and many are left wondering if love is worth the potential friendship sacrifice.

Comment from u/WhimsicalDreamer

Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section.

Final Thoughts

This story serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities in navigating friendships and romantic interests. The OP's choice to date her friend's ex without disclosure raises questions about loyalty, trust, and the ethical dilemmas that often accompany love. Are you team OP, believing in the right to pursue happiness, or do you side with Emily, valuing honesty above all? How would you handle this complicated love triangle?

Emily did not just lose Alex, she might feel like she lost OP too.

Before you decide, read about the AITA fight over keeping dating her former crush secret.

Should I Tell My Best Friend Im Dating Her Former Crush?