AITA for Dating My Friends Ex Without Permission?

A 27-year-old woman thought she was playing it cool, then dropped the bomb: she’s dating her friend Elena’s ex, Alex. It sounds simple on paper, but in practice, it’s the kind of relationship twist that makes group chats go silent and phone calls go unanswered.

Elena and OP have been close for five years, so when Elena dated Alex for almost two years, OP ended up getting to know him too. After the breakup six months ago, OP says Alex helped her through a tough time, and things turned romantic. The problem? OP never told Elena, because she wasn’t sure how she’d react.

Now Elena has found out, she’s calling it “girl code” betrayal, and OP is stuck in the middle of two people who matter.

Original Post

I (27F) have been friends with Elena (26F) for about five years. We're super close, or at least I thought we were.

Anyways, Elena dated this guy, Alex (28M), for almost two years. They broke up about six months ago.

For background, during their relationship, I got to know Alex pretty well too because we all hung out a lot. Fast forward a bit, and Alex and I started getting closer after Elena and him broke up.

He really helped me through a tough time, and one thing led to another, and now we're dating. The thing is, I never talked to Elena about this because I wasn't sure how she'd react.

I saw her for the first time in a while, and she asked us point-blank if we were seeing each other. I admitted it, and she got really upset, saying I broke 'girl code' and that it was a betrayal.

She's ignoring my calls and texts now. I feel caught between two people I care about.

Alex and I really like each other, but I never wanted to hurt Elena. So, AITA?

This story highlights a classic dilemma in friendships: when does someone’s ex become fair game? The OP’s decision to date Elena’s ex, Alex, raises questions about loyalty and timing. She’s been friends with Elena for five years, which complicates the emotional landscape. Elena’s recent breakup after a two-year relationship means she’s likely still processing her feelings, making this situation feel like a betrayal to many.

On the other hand, the OP might genuinely like Alex, and feelings can’t always be controlled. This tension between emotional honesty and perceived loyalty is what makes situations like this so universally relatable and contentious.

Comment from u/PizzaLover55

Comment from u/SunflowerDaze

Comment from u/BlueMoonShine

That moment when Elena asked point-blank if OP and Alex were seeing each other is where the whole “we’re basically fine” illusion cracked.

The 'Girl Code' Dilemma

The whole idea of 'girl code' often comes into play in these scenarios, but it’s a murky concept at best. Elena likely feels the sting of betrayal, even if OP didn’t directly break any explicit rules. The unspoken nature of these codes can create a lot of confusion and resentment. OP might argue she didn’t owe Elena permission, especially if they weren't together anymore, yet the emotional fallout could be significant.

This conflict reflects a deeper issue: how do we balance our desires with our friends' feelings? It’s a question that resonates well beyond this single post.

Comment from u/TechNinja007

Comment from u/GamerGalForever

Comment from u/CookieMonster82

After six months of silence, the fact that Alex was involved in OP’s tough time makes Elena’s anger feel extra personal, not just procedural.

This is similar to someone dating a friend’s ex even after their approval was clearly a no.

The Community's Divided Response

Reactions from the Reddit community reveal the complexities of this situation. Some users argue that dating an ex is a betrayal, while others empathize with the OP's feelings for Alex. This division underscores how personal experiences shape our views on friendship and relationships. For some, the idea of a friend dating an ex feels like an ultimate betrayal, while others advocate for personal happiness.

The mixed responses also highlight the broader societal expectations placed on women in friendships, particularly surrounding loyalty and support. It’s fascinating to see how these nuanced opinions reflect diverse personal histories and values.

Comment from u/AdventureSeeker99

Comment from u/OceanBreeze23

Comment from u/CoffeeAddict2021

OP’s explanation that “one thing led to another” lands differently when Elena watched them all hang out during Alex and her relationship.

Why Timing Matters

Timing is everything in relationships, and in this case, it adds another layer of complexity. Elena’s fresh breakup means she’s likely still emotionally vulnerable, which makes the OP’s choice to pursue Alex feel even more jarring. The OP might argue that she didn’t intend to hurt anyone and that her feelings for Alex developed naturally, but the timing significantly alters the perception of her actions.

In a world where breakups can leave deep emotional scars, the OP’s decision could be seen as insensitive, even if it was unintentional. This situation emphasizes how the emotional timelines of friendships and relationships can clash spectacularly.

Comment from u/MoonlightDreamer

Comment from u/StarryNightSky

Now with Elena ignoring OP’s calls and texts, OP is stuck wondering if dating Alex was romance, or a straight-up betrayal.</p>

We're curious to hear your perspective. Share your thoughts in the comments.

This story captures the tangled web of friendships, love, and the unspoken rules that govern them.

The situation with the Reddit user, Elena, and Alex showcases the tension that often arises when friendship collides with romantic interest. The user’s choice to date Alex after he and Elena broke up just six months ago feels particularly sensitive, as Elena is likely still processing her emotions from that relationship. Even if there aren't strict rules about dating a friend's ex, the timing and the closeness of their friendship complicate matters, leading to Elena's feelings of betrayal. This scenario highlights how personal desires can clash with unspoken expectations in friendships, leaving everyone involved feeling hurt and conflicted.

OP may have gained a boyfriend, but she just lost the friend she thought she’d never have to choose between.

Before you decide who is “right,” read this AITA on dating Elena’s ex Alex.