Postpartum Mom Defends Wearing Tank Tops: AITA for Prioritizing Comfort Over SILs Modesty Concerns?

A 28-year-old new mom refused to change her postpartum wardrobe, and it turned into a whole family drama faster than her baby could finish a feed. She’s nursing, she runs hot, and tank tops are the only thing that keeps her comfortable.

Then Judy, her sister-in-law, drops the “dress more modestly” comment, like a nursing tank top is some kind of moral emergency. The weird part is Judy herself is constantly showing skin, including crop tops, so the criticism lands as pure hypocrisy. One pushback later, things get awkward, and now the tension is lingering like leftover baby spit-up on a shirt.

Here’s the full story of how a simple clothing choice turned into a real test of who gets to police comfort in this family.

Original Post

I (28F) recently gave birth and have been nursing my baby. It gets really hot, and wearing tank tops has been my go-to for comfort since postpartum hormones make me overheated.

My sister-in-law, Judy, mentioned that I should dress 'more modestly,' implying the tank tops were too revealing. Here's the thing - Judy lives in crop tops and doesn't shy away from showing skin herself.

I found it hypocritical for her to comment on my clothing choices. For background, Judy and I have had a decent relationship before this, and she's usually not one to be overly critical.

When I pushed back and mentioned her own choice of clothing, things got a bit awkward between us.

Despite her comment, I continued to wear tank tops because they're practical for nursing and help me stay cool during this time. Judy seems to avoid the topic now, but there's an underlying tension that wasn't there before.

So, AITA for sticking to my choice of clothing despite Judy's objection, or should I have considered her perspective more?

Moreover, prioritizing comfort can enhance bonding with their newborns, allowing mothers to focus on nurturing rather than feeling self-conscious about their appearance.

Comment from u/Starry-EyedDreamer23

Comment from u/CoffeeAddict87

Comment from u/AdventureSeeker99

Judy’s “more modestly” comment hits right when OP is already dealing with heat and nursing, so it doesn’t feel like advice, it feels like control.

Relationship dynamics can heavily influence personal choices, especially in family settings.

Comment from u/PizzaLover1234

Comment from u/MusicFanatic786

Comment from u/SunnySideUp22

OP fights back by pointing out Judy wears crop tops too, and suddenly their once-decent relationship is stuck in awkward silence.

Tank-top policing and postpartum heat isn’t the only etiquette fight, this takeout tipping debate is similar to the Reddit argument over whether you should tip for takeout orders.

Societal expectations can disproportionately affect women, especially around motherhood.

Comment from u/TechGeekGirl

Comment from u/Bookworm124

Comment from u/Snickerdoodle19

The tension doesn’t disappear, it just goes quiet, because Judy seems to avoid the topic now instead of apologizing or dropping it.

A healthcare professional emphasizes that wearing what feels good can support physical healing and emotional stability. New mothers are encouraged to embrace their comfort choices without guilt, as this can contribute to positive mental health outcomes.

Additionally, maintaining open lines of communication with family members regarding such choices can preempt misunderstandings and reinforce supportive relationships. Establishing personal boundaries around clothing choices can ultimately lead to a more harmonious family environment.

Comment from u/GymRat_95

OP keeps wearing the tank tops for comfort and practicality, and the family dinner energy never really comes back after that exchange.

What do you think about this situation? Let us know in the comments.

Ultimately, the journey through postpartum challenges can be complex, often influenced by societal norms and family dynamics.

The new mother's decision to prioritize tank tops during her postpartum period underscores the fundamental need for comfort during a time of significant physical and emotional adjustment. This narrative illustrates the ongoing struggle between personal expression and societal expectations. The sister-in-law's remarks appear to echo broader cultural norms regarding modesty, yet they also expose a potential hypocrisy that often ignites family tensions.

Nobody wins when Judy tries to police OP’s nursing comfort, and the family dinner does not end well.

Want another tense household standoff, read about the wife refusing vacation plans with her husband to earn extra money: AITA for Saying No to Vacation Plans with My Husband?.