Should I Encourage My Friend to Confess Their Feelings to Their Crush?
AITA for advising my friend to confess feelings to their crush despite potential consequences? Sharing my perspective led to fear of impacting their friendship.
A 27-year-old man is stuck in the middle of a love story that could either blossom into something sweet, or detonate the entire friend group.
His close friend, Sarah, 25, finally admitted she’s been catching feelings for their mutual buddy, Alex, 28NB. The problem is Alex has zero obvious romantic interest, and Sarah is terrified that one honest confession will mess up the dynamic they’ve had for years.
To make it worse, Sarah has been dropping hints instead of speaking up, and OP told her to be direct, then immediately started worrying he meddled.
Original Post
I (27M) have a close friend, Sarah (25F), who recently confided in me that she's developed feelings for our mutual friend, Alex (28NB). Sarah is really anxious about ruining our friend group dynamic if she tells Alex how she feels.
For context, Sarah and Alex have been friends for years, but Alex has shown no romantic interest in Sarah. Sarah's afraid of the friendship changing if she reveals her feelings.
She's been dropping hints, but Alex hasn't picked up on them. I know Sarah well and noticed how much she likes Alex, so I suggested she should be honest and tell them directly, emphasizing that it's better to know how Alex feels rather than regret not saying anything later.
Sarah is torn between risking their friendship and accepting unrequited feelings. She values both Alex's friendship and her emotional honesty.
I want her to be happy, but I don't want to meddle too much. Sarah asked for my advice, and I gave it, but now I'm wondering if I overstepped.
If things go south between Sarah and Alex, I fear she might blame me for pushing her. I want her to be confident but worry I might have influenced her too much.
So AITA?
Comment from u/whimsical_cookie123
Comment from u/LunaStarlight22
Comment from u/UnicornLover99
Comment from u/CoffeeAddict75
Comment from u/gamer_gal_27
This is similar to the OP who debated confessing her feelings for their mutual friend to her bestie.
Comment from u/catlady23
Comment from u/beachbum2020
Comment from u/TheRealDeal_87
Comment from u/musiclover42
Comment from u/PizzaFanatic101
Sarah confided to OP about her crush on Alex, and that is when the anxiety really started to creep in.
OP basically pushed the “just tell them” angle, even while Sarah was scared her friendship with Alex would change overnight.
Now OP is replaying every hint Sarah dropped and every moment Alex didn’t pick up on them, wondering if he nudged too hard.
The real tension hits when Sarah might blame OP if things go sideways between her and Alex, ruining more than just the romance.
What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.
OP might have meant well, but he’s now afraid he became the villain in Sarah’s love story.
Then see how love, friendship, and betrayal collide when OP gave dating advice to a friend and pursued their crush, in this AITA about giving dating advice then going for the crush.
