Debating Dog Sitting: Friends Aggressive Great Dane vs. Family Vacation Safety

Some dog-sitting requests are cute, some are chaotic, and this one is straight-up a power struggle with a Great Dane. The OP is a 35-year-old guy who loves dogs, but he has history with his friend’s big, guard-trained animal that has a habit of lunging at strangers and barking like it’s always go-time.

Now his 32-year-old friend is leaving for a two-week family vacation and wants him to take over. She insists the dog is “harmless” if you handle him right, but OP has watched him act aggressive without warning, and he’s also got his own family trip already planned for the same dates.

What makes it messy is that when OP mentions the conflict, she pushes back hard, even implying their friendship could suffer if he won’t do the sit.

Original Post

So I'm (35M) a huge dog lover but have had a rocky history with one particular dog - my friend's aggressive Great Dane. Quick context, they got this dog as a guard dog due to some security concerns at their home.

For background, my friend (32F) asked me to dog sit the Great Dane while they go on a 2-week family vacation. She assured me that the dog is harmless if you know how to handle him, but I've seen him lunge at strangers and bark aggressively without warning.

I have my doubts about managing such a large, powerful dog. The dilemma starts here - I planned a much-needed family vacation during the same time as their trip.

When I told my friend about this conflict, she got upset, stating that I should prioritize her dog over my vacation. She even hinted that our friendship would suffer if I don't help out.

My family is worried about potential risks involving their safety and our own pets around the Great Dane. Now I'm torn between keeping the peace with my friend and ensuring my family's safety and peace of mind during our own vacation.

So, WIBTA if I refuse to dog sit for my friend's aggressive Great Dane while we're away, even if it strains our friendship?

Aggressive behavior in dogs often stems from fear rather than inherent malice.

Comment from u/CoffeeBeanLover_87

Comment from u/AdventureSeeker99

Comment from u/pizza_is_my_savior

When OP remembers the Dane lunging at strangers and barking “without warning,” his gut says this is not a casual favor.

This evaluation should include discussions with the owner about the dog's triggers and any previous incidents of aggression. Such steps can provide insightful data on the dog's behavior. If the dog displays threatening behavior, it's not only prudent to decline dog sitting but also to communicate these concerns effectively to maintain the friendship.

Comment from u/quirky_bookworm_22

Comment from u/SunflowerDreamer76

Comment from u/gamingpuppy2021

That’s when the friend drops the “prioritize my dog over your vacation” line, and suddenly it’s not just about schedules.

This is similar to the $60 water heater fix feud, where a busy dad got accused of scamming and things escalated fast.

Conflict in friendships often stems from unmet expectations and miscommunication.

Comment from u/art_love_forever

Comment from u/daisy_lover_45

Comment from u/coding_genius21

Meanwhile, OP’s family is side-eyeing the whole plan, especially with their own pets and personal safety in the mix.

This could include identifying a backup sitter or professional trainer who can assist if the dog's behavior becomes unmanageable.

He suggests that if a sitter feels uncomfortable, it's better to be honest and seek alternatives. Ultimately, prioritizing safety ensures that both the pet and the sitter have a positive experience.

Comment from u/space_explorer_007

Now OP is stuck weighing peace with his friend against the very real risk of being responsible for a powerful guard dog for two weeks.

Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section.

The decision to dog sit an aggressive Great Dane is fraught with complexities that extend beyond mere friendship considerations. It is essential to comprehend the nuances of animal behavior and engage in candid conversations with both the dog owner and oneself. The situation highlights the importance of proactive strategies to address potential risks linked to aggressive pets. Prioritizing safety not only shields the sitter from potential harm but also honors the friendship at stake. In the end, this dilemma illustrates the delicate balance between caring for a beloved pet and ensuring the well-being of all involved.

This scenario illustrates the timeless conflict between loyalty and self-preservation.

Refusing to dog sit the aggressive Great Dane might save the friendship, but it’ll also save everyone else from a bad outcome.

Wait until you hear how a “family backbone” turned into a “family villain” in one talk, starting with a shocking money comment.